Showing posts with label Sola Scriptura. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sola Scriptura. Show all posts

Saturday, December 26, 2020

Rightly Dividing the Word of Truth-2 Timothy 2:15

This is an often overlooked verse of Scripture, which is interesting given how it's about Scripture.

There is a common attitude among Evangelical Christians that goes "how dare you suggest some parts of Scripture are more important then others", they feel the integrity of Scripture considers it important they label all Scripture equally as authoritative for every purpose.

In the same Epistle chapter 3 verse 16 Paul says all Scripture is profitable for doctrine, reproof, correction, instruction in righteousness.  But maybe those should be "or" rather then "and", the KJV uses neither.

As charming an Ideal as it is to try and treat every single obscure statement of Scripture as being equally as important as what Jesus said on The Cross or Moses on Mt Sinai, that's incredibly unhelpful.  The Bible is a big book, you can in theory read all of it in a few days if you really pushed yourself, or played an audio book version at double speed.  But you are not going to properly consume it or understand it that way.  So at the very least we should maybe give new Christians some guidelines to what they need to read first.

To a certain extent I think Christians should consider even the least of the New Testament higher priority then even the most vital parts of the Hebrew Bible (commonly called the "Old Testament").  That stuff is all important but Christians should always be reading it through a New Testament filter.  But that is in tension with another part of me that dislikes when Christians are in denial of how often the Christological significance of some passages were not always their original main point.

Top priority should be the life story, teachings and example of Jesus.  We get that in the 4 Gospels and very beginning of Acts (where many Bibles have the words of Jesus in Red) and then the entire Book of Revelation.  

Then next under Jesus in Authority would be the 12 Disciples, and almost about equal with them the Beloved Disciple/Bethany Siblings and maybe also the Maternal half siblings of Jesus.  We get their teachings in the first 15 Chapters of Acts and the General Epistles, and also arguably the narrative voices of Matthew, Mark (who wrote what Peter preached) and the Fourth Gospel.

The rest of the New Testament is basically Paul.  It might concern you that I'm aiding and abetting the Anti-Paul cultists by categorizing him as the least authoritative New Testament voice, but it's consistent with Paul's own claims, he defined himself as the least of the Apostles in 1 Corinthians 15:9.

Judaism traditionally divides the Hebrew Bible into three categories, The Law or Torah which is the Pentateuch the Five Books of Moses.  And then The Prophets and The Writings.  New Testament references commonly taken as referring to the "Old Testament" as a whole are actually just saying The Law and The Prophets.

Now The New Testament is arguably including in the Prophets some material the traditional Jewish reckoning does not, Jesus calls both Daniel and Jonah Prophets, and Peter calls David a Prophet in Acts 2, Davidic Psalms are the most commonly quoted Psalms in the New Testament, but not the only ones, for example Asaph's are quoted and there is justification for labeling him a Prophet as well based on comparing 1 Samuel 1:9 to 2 Chronicles 29:30.

But the New Testament never actually unambiguously quotes the post Torah historical books.  It alludes to history from them, and quotes Psalms they also quote, and Elijah once, but that's it, their overall narrative voice isn't endorsed at all.  They are important for providing context, but perhaps they shouldn't be viewed uncritically as history books.  I have a prior post on comparing Chronicles to Samuel-Kings.

And I have also discussed how the New Testament speaks rather dismissively of Solomon, so perhaps the writings attributed to Solomon should be ranked at the very bottom?

This post isn't me arguing anything should be thrown out.  But when dealing with things like apparent contradictions we should consider who said the verse in question and for what purpose.

Monday, April 6, 2020

There is a theory that Mark's Gospel was originally written in Latin.

I've already argued on this Blog from Biblical References that John Mark spent time in Rome but not Peter.

Mark contains over half of the New Testament's Laitnisms, Laitnisms are inevitable just because of Rome's influence at the time.  But Mark a couple of times actually explains Semitic words using Latin ones.

Now I should clarify that no one proposing this thinks The Vulgate version of Mark is the original Latin version of Mark.  That text is still viewed as Jerome's translation of a Greek Mark as it is for the rest of the New Testament.

David Bruce Gain is one scholar who's been a proponent of this theory.  He has made his own personal reconstruction of what he thinks the original Latin text was, and his own English Translation of that Latin version.  I do disagree with him sometimes, for one he ends Mark with Mark 16:8 which is a theory I reject and may be the subject of it's own post in the future.

And on the subject of Mark 16:1 I disagree with "the Sabbath was past" being an interpolation "based on Matthew 28:1".  What Mark says here is distinct from how it's phrased in Matthew, and because neither Latin or Greek had a word for "week" in the first century this detail was necessary to clarify that the Sabbath following the Passion was over.  Torah literate readers would see it as referring to the instructions for First Fruits.

There is a limit to how much I'd be willing to change Mark based on this theory.  If Mark was originally in Latin I still feel the Textus Receptus (not any Alexandrian manuscripts) version of Mark is a very accurate Greek Translation of that Latin.  And I also think the Peshita version of Mark is a translation of the original Latin not the Greek.

I believe the Simon of Matthew 16 and Mark 14 was a Jar-Maker not a Leper, what that would mean for the textual history of Mark or Matthew (which I believe was originally written in Hebrew) I can't say for certain yet.  Though the ablity of the Peshita to get it right if it was using a Latin source even though the Greek got it wrong from the same source implies that Latin text transliterated rather then translated the title.

The robe placed on Jesus at his Trial and Execution I believe was a red robe that the soldiers described as purple mockingly and that's how we reconcile apparent contradictions there.  What's interesting is how only Mark mentioned the Color Purple.  So Mark has Jesus seemingly clothed in Purple with a Crown of Thrones and a staff, and presumably blood on his face.  Mark is making Jesus look like the Triumphitor of a Roman Triumph.  Yet there are two roles in the Triumph Jesus is playing, he's also the enemy of Rome (proclaimed King of The Jews) being humiliated and sacrificed to the Heavenly Father.

Now there are reasons why my Universal Salvation allies might be a little worried about suggesting any book was originally in Latin, we like to blame Latin translations for the issues we have with how certain passages read in modern English.

However Mark has no equivalent to Matthew 25's parables, I have argued for Universal Salvation being compatible with the KJV, and again we don't think the Vulgate is the original.  4th and 5th Century Latins are a factor in these problems, but Greek speakers like Cyril of Alexandria also helped.  I think we've perhaps been too hard on Tertullian for example.

David Bruce Gain's translation of his reconstruction of Mark 3:29, the only verse in Mark where the KJV uses "Eternal" in reference to punishment.  "but one who blasphemes against the dedicated breath will be penalized.He will be guilty of wrongdoing for ever".

This reading fits pretty well with how I interpret the "unpardonable sin" issue based on studying it mainly via Matthew.  This is the one sin where you can't get out of the punishment by genuinely repenting.  But that doesn't mean the punishment is Endless Torment or Annihilation.

Later in Chapter 9 David Bruce Gain's proposed original Latin does use a Latin transliteration of Gehenna every time you see Gehenna in the Greek, it's never simply "translated" infernus like the Vulgate often does.  I don't know if he has pre-Vulgate texts to support that or if it's just an inference.

However I do feel Gain is wrong on verse 49, he removed all references to Salt and has that verse just refer to being consumed by fire.  Now I think it's possible his version of verse 50 could be correct, but even he still has salt being referenced in verse 50, he has pay off with no set up.

He recognizes that this section is drawing on the very last verse of the book of Isaiah.  But that's not the only Old Testament reference in mind here, there is also Leviticus 2:13 and Deuteronomy 29:23., and maybe also Ezekiel 16:4, 43:24 and 47:11.

Update:  I'm starting to feel like I'm guilty of some hypocrisy in how I treated the Vulgate up above.

I strongly advocate for favoring the Received Text when it comes to the Greek (Textus Receptus over Alexandrian variations) the Aramaic (Peshita) and even for favoring the Ethiopic version of the Apocalypse of Peter over the Akhmim manuscript IF I were to entertain treating it as canonical.  But once I became aware of the possibility of a book being originally in Latin the anti Vulgate sentiments of my Protestantism clouded my judgment.

My interpretation of Mark 3:29 is perfectly compatible with the Vulgate reading, since the word it uses in place of the KJV's "Damnation" is "delicti" which Google translate says simply means "offense" and "in danger of " actually means "guilty of".  So "is guiltily of an eternal offense" works perfectly.  I still consider Matthew closer to what Jesus actually said, but this can be a valid expression of the same idea.

Also, I was flat out wrong on Gehenna, the Vulgate never "translates" it Infernus, every single time Gehenna is in the Greek the Vulgate says Gehenna too.  Now David Bruce Gain's reconstruction has a different transliteration, but that's not a difference worth slipping hairs over.

Hades is what the Vulgate likes to "translate" infernus, but Hades doesn't appear in Mark.  Hell in the context of what Hel/Hella was in Norse mythology was originally a perfectly fine equivalent to the Hebrew Sheol and Greek Hades, it's using the same word for Hades that caused what Hell means to be confusing.  In 1 Corinthians 15:55 the Hades/Grave/Hell half of the verse is dropped entirely which mutilates the very poetic structure of the passage.  Somehow the Vulgate uses both inferni and tartarum in 2 Peter 2:4.

My belief that Infernus was fundamentally wrong was a mistaken understanding of Latin combined with my nerdy reasons for thinking it should have been Orcus.  I had it in my head that it meant fiery first and became a name for Hell when used in Bible translations.  It's the reverse however, it's literal Latin meaning is "the lower world".   The Aeneid, a Latin epic poem inspired by Homer's epics uses Infernus of Hades.

I think every place where I explicitly expressed disagreement with Gain would put me in agreement with the Vulgate.

Except for what I hypothesized about Simon the Leper, the Vulgate like Gain definitely says Leper here.  I'm also starting to doubt Hebrew Matthew will support the Jar-Maker reading given what I've seen from people talking about the known texts so far.  So it seems like the Peshita may be the one guilty of a scribal error there.

The fact that the name of Bethany probably comes from "House of the Poor" or "House of affliction" supports the idea that Lepers would be concerned.  I do believe the Bethany siblings themselves were wealthy, probably devoting much of their time to helping the poor in this area.  It's possible Simon wasn't called "The Leper" because he was a Leper but because of an association with helping and caring for them.

Maybe the meaning of the name of Simon/Simeon/Simonis is the key, which means hearing or to regard.  Maybe it meant the House of hearing the Lepers?

There is also the theory that Simon the Leper and Lazarus are the same person.  I've long been unsatisfied by the theory that the etymology of Lazarus is a form of the Hebrew Eleazer, every Hebrew name that begins with El still has the E in their NT Greek forms.  And Josephus used Lazarus in Wars 5.18.7 even though he used Eleazar often.  Well the Hebrew word Leper used in the Torah in Leviticus 13 and 14 is Tsara or Zara, the Hebrew letter Tzadi usually becomes a Zeta in Greek.  And L' is a Hebrew prefix usually interpreted to mean "to" but seems to sometimes be used as an alternate definitive article.  During Greco-Roman times if people knew the Hellenic/Latin words for this condition began with an L the L prefix here could have been wordplay.  The other Lazarus in The Bible in Luke 16 seems to be described as a Leper even though traditionally no word for Leper is used there, and since it's a parable personal names shouldn't be used there.

Another Update: Vetus Latina

I had thought that Pre-Vulgate versions existed only in fragments.  But this is an independent received tradition that existed along side the Vulgate virtually until Trent, and there is a roughly 350 dated manuscript of the Gospels.

Friday, October 26, 2018

The Gospel According to The Beloved Disciple

This post is kind of a follow up to my Heresies of Asia Minor post, and with also some prior groundwork laid by my Mary Magdalene and Bethany post.

One of the reasons that I can't put too much stock in what The Early Church Fathers said is that the Patristic Tradition is pretty unanimous that the Gospel we commonly call "The Gospel According to John" was written by John Son of Zebedee brother of James who one of the Twelve.  But the fact is the text of that Gospel tells us who wrote it, and it's not one of The Twelve or someone named John.

At the end of The Gospel we're told "The Disciple who Jesus Loved" wrote The Gospel (21:20-23).  Normally an analysis will say Chapter 13:23-25 is the first time this Disciple is mentioned.  However if you just read The Gospel without bringing prior assumptions into it, it's clear that this verse is identifying someone we were already introduced to.

But first I need to note that most of the traditional Beloved Disciple verses use Agape, but chapter 20:2 uses Phileo.

In chapters 11 verse 3 the sisters of Lazarus inform Jesus of his death by saying "he whom thou lovest is sick" using Phileo.  Verse 5 says that Jesus loved Martha and her sister and Lazarus using Agape.  In verse 36 the Judeans observe "look how Jesus loved him" using Phileo again referring to Lazarus.

Chapter 12 depicts Lazarus sitting next to Jesus just as the Beloved Disciple does in 13:23-24.

The argument that the Beloved Disciple must be one of the Twelve is dependent on verses from the Synoptics that are taken as saying only the Twelve were at the Last Supper, but they don't actually say that, they emphasize the Twelve being there but do not say it was only the Twelve. In fact it is made clear in the Synpotics that someone else owned the house they had it in.

Chapter 21 does mention the Sons of Zebedee, so if you wanna assume the Beloved Disciple can't be mentioned by any other designation in this Gospel, that rules them out as well. 

Others have proposed this theory before me, but I have some differences from them.  For example I'm rather skeptical of the whole connecting Lazarus to the family of Beothus theory.

http://www.alanrudnick.org/2017/04/13/john-was-not-the-disciple-whom-jesus-loved/

https://www.beliefnet.com/columnists/bibleandculture/2007/01/was-lazarus-the-beloved-disciple.html

I also like to stress based on 11:5 that the designation can be expanded to include his Sisters, which helps explain 20:2, and I also still lean towards it being Mary who was entrusted with his mother in 19:25.

I also disagree with the idea that the ending of the Gospel is implying the Beloved Disciple had died before it's final publication.

But biggest of all, I don't think John the Presbyter was a student of the Beloved Disciple.  I don't think either John or the Bethany family ever went to Ephesus, Ephesus is mentioned quite a bit in the New Testament with no hints at any of them being there.  But Revelation 2 does refer to there being False Apostles in Ephesus, I think one of them claimed to be John and claimed credit for all five books traditionally ascribed to John, and then came to be sometimes known as John the Presbyter based on the 2nd and 3rd Epistles.  And because the "Apostolic Succession" of the early Church went back to his alleged students like Ignatius and Polycarp, that false attribution came to be accepted at face value.  In the authentic writings of Ignatius and Polycarp they never claim to be disciples of John or anyone else, and it seems Papias distinguished the John he knew from any of the Apostles.

There is an ancient Eastern Extra-Biblical Tradition that Lazarus received his Bishop's Omophorion from The Virgin Mary. It was apparently something she wove for him.  So there is some evidence their association was remembered.

Most even Atheist scholars agree that all three Epistles commonly called "of John" probably have the same author as The Gospel.  The first of them I don't even view as an Epistle since it doesn't have an Epistle style introduction or ending.  I think it was an Appendix to the Gospel.

It's Revelation that scholars have trouble seeing as being by the same author.  And I think that argument can hold up better then attempts to deny certain Paulian letters had the same author.  The issue is that usually The Gospel is given first dibs on being the true Son of Zebedde (though plenty of Atheists think none could have been written by a Galileen Fisherman) while I'm pointing out that Revelation is the only of these books who's author actually claims to be named John.

These books being dated to between 90 and 100 AD is often itself seen as evidence against them being written by Eye Witnesses because of the modern obsession with saying people didn't live as long back then.  The problem with that narrative is "average" life-span statistics are skewed by how there used to be higher infant mortality rates.  I think the Twelve Disciples were younger then Jesus to begin with, and Paul was younger then the Twelve.  In every era of history some people have successfully lived to 100, therefore some people born around 5 BC could have made it to 96 AD.

Quadratus letter to Hadrian says some people Jesus healed and rose form the dead were still alive at the time he wrote that letter.  That's a category Lazarus specifically fits into.  Simeon the second Bishop of Jerusalem was said to have been 120 when he was martyred during the reign of Trajan according to Eusebius.  If some theories about the Bethany family are true, he could have been the father of Lazarus and his sisters, or the same person as Lazarus, because the Simon of Matthew 26 and Mark 14 seems to have something to do with the Bethany family when you cross reference it with John 12.

Below is additional theorizing that is much more speculative.

Maybe part of the reason the Gospel became associated with the name of John is how it talks about John The Baptist at the beginning.  It's not the only Gospel to kind of begin with John but it's treatment of John is arguably unique.  John is the first personal name mentioned in the text.

The name Lazarus is often thought to be a nickname. (It being a presumed form of Eleazar never sat right with me, all other El theophoric names still begin an E in their Greek forms, and I don't think a spelling like Lazarus is ever used in Josephus of someone known to be an Eleazar.)  A theory that among other things complicates how he relates to the Parable in Luke 16.  So he could be someone also named John which was a common name.  However there are the Ossuaries at Dominus Flevit which have a Mary, Martha and Eleazer together.

Wikipedia pages about the Eastern Traditions of Lazarus and his sisters say they preached the Gospel in many lands not just Cyrpus, but I can't find specifics about that.  What I find unlikely about the Cyprus tradition is that Lazarus would be ordained by Paul and Barnabas when Paul's own definitions of Apostolic Authority would place Lazarus ahead of him.  Paul's time on Cyrpus with Barnabas is recorded in Acts 13 with no reference to them visiting Kition or ordaining any Bishops or meeting Lazarus and the Bethany sisters.

If the traditions of Lazarus on Cyprus do have some truth to them, it's notable that they only account for about 30 years after his Resurrection, which takes us to 60 AD or 66 AD at the latest.  I'm confident he did live a lot longer then that. 

Update April 2020:  I have decided that The Disciple who Jesus Agape when used of a single individual is Mary, and Magdalene and the sister of Lazarus are the same Mary.  And The Disciple who Jesus Phileo when used of a single individual is Lazarus.

I have abandoned my past flirtation with the idea of Mary Agdalene as Jesus Sister.  But I do still think "Mother's Sister" in John 19:25 should probably means "Maternal sister" and so I now think Mary of Cleophas is one of his Sisters. 

In verse 26 when Jesus "his mother, and the disciple standing by, whom he apagao" both character refereed to here are ones identified in the prior verse.  The male pronouns are possibly just translating pronouns not actually originally meant to be gender specific.  When He says refers to this disciple as "son" so His Mother he means the legal meaning of sonship, not biology or gender.

Saturday, October 20, 2018

How much should Christians Agree with Mainstream Academia on the Origins of The New Testament?

There are a lot of Christian scholars trying to not break with mainstream Secular Academia on when particularly The Gospels were written as much as possible, Brad Jersak, Inspiring Philosophy, the Casual Historian, ect.  Part of it is to avoid hypocrisy, since we appeal to the general consensus of mainstream Secular Academia when refuting the Christ Myth Hypothesis and other pseudo-historical conspiracy theories of the New Atheist movement.

Well in a way I'm not going to be as radical as those being the opposite on this would be either.

I think Greek Matthew and Greek Mark were possibly written when they are currently dated, between 60 and 80 AD.  But Matthew I think was originally in Hebrew and that Hebrew Matthew could be Q, and Mark I think was originally written in Syriac Aramaic in Mesopotamia, where Peter was.  Both I think were written before 42 AD, maybe even before 37 AD.

Luke is the only Gospel where I need to place the Greek Text sooner then mainstream scholars do, which I then place Acts at about the same time.  And I'm doing so out of Faith right now and not claiming to have a solid argument to do so.

When it comes to Revelation, the disagreement is chiefly about who wrote it not when since I place it's authorship when most Futurists do.  The disagreement about who is primarily about if it could have the same author as John's Gospel and Epistles, since textual scholars can't really claim to know whether either was ever a Galilean fisherman or not.

I'm actually very open to suggesting Revelation had a different author from the other books attributed to John.  The difference is when most open the door to this distinction it's The Gospel who's given first dibs on being written by John brother of James son of Zebedee who was one of the Twelve.  However it's only Revelation who's actual text identifies it's author as bearing the name of John.  The Gospel says at the end the "Disciple whom Jesus Loved" wrote it, and using that Gospel to interpret itself, three disciples are associated with that description in chapter 11, none were among the twelve, they are the three siblings, Lazarus, Martha and Mary of Bethany.  The first Epistle doesn't identify it's author in any way which is why I'm not sure it truly qualifies as an Epistle, frankly I have come to view it as an appendix to Gospel of the Beloved Disciple.  The authors' of 2nd and 3rd John simply refer to themselves as the Elder.

When it comes to the arguments against the writings of Paul or Peter having the same author, I find myself wondering if the diverse literary careers of many modern writers would seem like they're the same to these scholars looking at them without already knowing.  Particularly when they say "stylistic and linguistic grounds".  Sometimes a writer's style changes over time, or they'll deliberately write in different styles.  And as far as linguistics go, the traditional authors of these books where not native to the language we have them in anyway.

We know Paul's letters were at least sometimes dictated because of how Tertius inserts himself into Romans 16, which is one of the Paulian Epistles considered pretty universally to be authentic, if it wasn't written by who we think of Paul as being then there was no Paul at all.  I think they were all dictated, and I think both Paul and Peter were actually reciting in Hebrew and the recorder was translating it, so the linguistic style could very often be the product of different recorders.  And Hebrews I think was originally written in Hebrew and what we have is a Greek translation that came later.

There is not quite universal agreement on which Paulian Epistles are authentic, Romans and Galatians are pretty agreed on, which is convenient for me since they include passages vital to my core ideologies.  There are 5 or 7 that are pretty commonly excluded by secular scholars, Hebrews which even believers will debate since it doesn't identify itself as Paul's at the start, the pastorals, and the sequel to Thessalonians. Disputing II Corinthians is actually more rare then I originally thought it was.

The arguments against the two sequels is mostly them allegedly contradicting their predecessor.  Again, how many modern sequels would fail the same test?  These are not like poorly planned fictional narratives however, the reason for these apparent contradictions is that in the 1st letters to these churches Paul was addressing specific issues they were dealing with.  The second letters were needed partly because some of what he said in the first was being misunderstood.  II Thessalonians 2 was written specifically to correct the the Imminence interpretation of I Thessalonians 4. 

The letters written to individuals rather then congregations could in many ways be different because of that difference in audience.  Just as Hebrews is different because it's written to a Jewish rather then Greek audience.  It's still consistent with Paul's faith over works message as shown by Chapter 11.  And you really can't complete Paul's 'we're not under the Law anymore' doctrine without bringing up Hebrews discussion of Jeremiah's prophecy of the Law being written on our Hearts.

For The Pastoral Epistles, most of the argument against their authenticity comes from the reasons to believe they came later.  They are dated later then most Paulian Epistles, but still not later then 100 AD, they're still in the first century.  Irenaeus quoted all three of them, writing around 180 AD, so they must have been around for awhile already.

It's relevant even to the "linguistic and stylistic grounds".

The problem is we are traditionally conditioned to assume Peter and Paul died in 64 or 67 AD, but The Bible never says that, and I have for reasons irrelevant to this issue rejected the traditions of either dying in Rome, and Peter I believe was never in Rome at all.  I think Paul's conversion happened in 37 or 38 AD, and I think he was in his 20s when that happened, pre-conversion Paul has a zealousness typical of a 20 something.  So if he was born between 10 and 17 AD, he could easily have lived into the 90s.  2 Timothy does seem to be written by an old man expecting to pass away soon.

Take for example this argument.
Literary style. Paul writes a characteristically dynamic Greek, with dramatic arguments, emotional outbursts, and the introduction of real or imaginary opponents and partners in dialogue. The Pastorals are in a quiet meditative style, far more characteristic of Hebrews or 1 Peter, or even of literary Hellenistic Greek in general, than of the Corinthian correspondence or of Romans, to say nothing of Galatians.
Maybe this difference is because he mellowed with age.  And also that the concerns the Church is facing have changed with the times.

The argument about "The letters as reflecting the characteristics of emergent Catholocism" is also related to this time-frame issue.  But I should note that I reject that these Epistles support the monarchical Church structure they are often presumed to support.  What "emergent Catholicism" means to secular scholars is different from Protestants debating how early what we object to about the Roman Church emerged, it's mostly about the development of Ignatius' organized church structure.

There are some who attempt to extend the late dating of the Pastorals into the second century, but I've already talked about evidence to view them as contemporary with Marital.

Colossians is apparently considered inauthentic by 60% of Scholars, and  Ephessians is now considered inauthentic partly because of presumed dependence on Colossians.  Again these arguments overlaps with reasons the Pastorals are dated later.  I think Paul might have been composing these two letters at the same time in a way where much of Colossians was written first yet it was finished last.  You see I agree with the argument that there is no Epistle to the Laodiceans, it was from Laodicea, and that the Epistle Paul alluded to there was Ephesians, which would have likely traveled through Laodicea if it went to Colossae.  And maybe these two were also post 70 AD.

Traditional timelines of the Epistles by people who question none of them already mostly tend to make the Agreed upon ones the earliest, with the rest being after he came to Rome in 62 AD at the soonest. Needless to say a lot of things changed for Paul then. He may well have had access to none of the recorders he had before, and the dialect of Greek in the western empire was likely different.  The outlier is 2nd Thessalonians which some seem to think was written right after the first, but I find that unlikely regardless of this dispute, I think it took time for Paul to realize that Church developed all new problems he needed to address.

There is also a lot of overlap between arguments against the Pastorals being authentic Paul and arguments against 2 Peter being the same author as 1 Peter.  But again a difference in what the author is concerned with talking about can be explained by when without doubting who wrote it.  But I also think Peter's two Epistles were written to different audiences, the first to Hellenistic Jewish communities in Asia Minor, and the second probably to a more Aramaic community.

I do not believe James and Jude were written by the half brothers of Jesus with those names, but rather by the James and Jude who were bothers among the 12.

Frankly a lot of the arguments about the authenticity of Letters attributed to the 12 reminds me of Anti-Stradfordian arguments, the massive incredulity that simple Galilean fisherman could have ever become capable of writing in such sophisticated Greek.  But this time it's those of us opposing that elitist argument who are viewed as fringe.  And Shakespeare doesn't have the excuse of being believed to have been Supernaturally assisted by The Holy Spirit.

And then there is the issue of referring to the Temple's Destruction being itself proof a book must have been written later cause we won't even entertain the notion of a real Prophecy.

So I guess The Wreck of the Titan: or, Futility must have been written after The Titanic sank.  And the Lone Gunman Pilot must have been written after September 11th 2001.  And that Simpsons episode where Donald Trump becomes President can't have been written any sooner then 2015.

"Wait, aren't you making Jesus prediction not even supernatural by comparing to things like that?"  Well I'm a Continuationsit who points out how sometimes The Holy Spirit even uses unbelievers like Balaam. In my opinion those predictions were supernatural whether to not the writer claimed to be a Prophet (with the Lone Gunman either it's supernatural or the Conspiracy Theorists are right).  But the fact still remains, if you think those things just happened because they were naturally predictable, well Jerusalem inevitably revolting against Rome and getting crushed it can be argued was predictable even in 30 AD.

The fact is Jerusalem falling and being lead away into Captivity again was already in Old Testament Prophecy, Daniel 9 and Zechariah 14 were prophecies made when Judea was returning from the Babylonian Captivity predicting another would be inevitable, in Daniel it's arguably even specifically said that The Temple will be destroyed again.  It was already in the Torah that this was a cycle that's going to keep playing itself out as long as Israel keeps backsliding.  So frankly it would have been weird for a 1st Century Jewish Prophet to not be saying all this is going to happen again.  And the Olivte Discourse does specifically cite Daniel, while Luke 21 uses terminology from Jeremiah "Desolation of Jerusalem".

What Jesus said is vague enough that both Atheist and Christian scholars will sometimes disagree on if Mark 13's account is about the 70 AD fall or the Bar-Kochba revolt.  Everything that seems really specific in what Jesus said arguably comes from echoing the fall to Babylon and/or drawing on what Daniel and Zechariah said.  Because the fact is the Roman Captivity was that history repeating itself on many levels.

In some cases it's not about "Prophecy after the fact" but just saying some things about the present scenario implied in a text must be post 70 AD.  Frankly however I feel that the author of Hebrews would have explicitly refereed to The Temple being destroyed to make his point if it had been.

Still some New Testament authors could have lived past 70 AD, Paul as I argued above, John who I think could have been a Nephew of Jesus, as well the Beloved Disciple Candidates, even Peter since I reject the tradition of him being in Rome at all.  And again since I don't view James and Jude as brothers of Jesus they could have.  Jude could have even if he was, Simeon the second Bishop of Jerusalem was a brother of Jesus who tradition says lived into the reign of Trajan.

Saturday, August 11, 2018

The Issue of Semitic Primacy for the New Testament

One of the issues to emerge out of the Hebrew Roots movement is attempting to argue the entire New Testament was written in either Hebrew and/or Aramaic rather then Greek.

As an opponent of how much Platonic and Aristolen Philosophy seeped into the Church via the Greco-Roman perspective of the "Early Church Fathers" I sympathize.  But I can't ultimately support this agenda, for the most part.

Yes all but one of the New Testament's Human Authors were Jewish.  But Acts 2 shows that Jews living outside Judea did not speak Hebrew all that well anymore, it would have been entirely Jews in the audience, people attending the Feast of Shavuot., but the reason the Gift of Tongs was needed was because their native languages were now those of the Gentile regions they lived in.  Following the conquests of Alexander, Greek was the International Language of the Eastern Mediterranean.  So even in places where both Greek and Aramaic were spoken, native Semites who knew Greek outnumbered Greeks who knew any Semitic language.

Matthew was originally written in Hebrew, multiple Early Church sources affirm that.  But they affirm that as something that makes it distinct from the others, at least the other Gospels.

I personally think Hebrew Matthew was possibly Q, a common source for both Greek Matthew and Luke.  Some Early Church comments about Hebrew Matthew imply it was only a collection of Sayings of Jesus making it fit the Q mold even better.

Luke was a Macedonian, writing his Gospel and Acts to a Theophilus, possibly partly as back ground information for Paul's trial before Nero (Nero was a total Hellenophile and so would have had no trouble reading/understanding Greek).  Luke and Acts were certainly written in Greek.

All of Paul's Epistles but maybe Hebrews would have to have been written in Greek (here is an article on why Romans wasn't in Latin).  Likewise with Revelation which was written to Seven Churches in the same region as three of Paul's letters, and 1st Peter was written to that region as well.  Paul wrote to three cities in Greece, to three men with Greco-Roman names, and to staunchly Greek parts of Asia Minor.  Acts itself reminds us how Greek the city of Ephesus was being devoted to Artemis.  Pergamon was the capital of a Hellenic Kingdom, and Laodicea was founded by a Seleucid ruler.

I'm very open to possible Aramaic Primacy for Mark.  As well as Hebrew or Aramaic Primacy for Hebrews, James, Jude and 2 Peter.  For Hebrews I'd consider Hebrew more likely and for 2 Peter Aramaic more likely.  Jude and James would be 50/50.  The Gospel and Epistles of John I still think are Greek, I'll return to that later.

For any books that I'm open to Aramaic Primacy, I strongly favor the Peshita (http://www.thearamaicscriptures.com/) over Old Syriac manuscripts like the the Four Gospels found on Sinai, an origin that parallels one of the Alexandrian Greek Texts.  Basically the Peshita should be viewed as the Textus Receptus of the Aramaic tradition.  The Peshita of Mark contains none of the common Alexandrian deviations for Mark, and yes that means it has all of Mark 16, however the Peshita versions of some other books do echo Alexandrian corruptions.

My reason for being interested in an Aramaic origin for Mark is that Mark is said by Papias to have been written based on what Peter preached.  Later traditions corrupted that to be in Rome but Papias originally didn't mention Rome. Peter was in fact in Mesopotamia, where Aramaic had been the main language since Neo-Assyrian times, and indeed Aramaic is the Language of the Peshita because it's The Bible of the Assyrian Church.  The first interesting implication I've noticed for the Peshita possibly being closer to the original for Mark is Simon The Leper being instead called Simon the Jar Maker.

The Gospel according to John and the Three Epistles that likely have the same author I also feel were likely to have been in Greek. Things like their stopping to explain certain Semitic key words to the reader.  Cepha/Kefa was a word both Hebrew and Aramaic had, it wasn't necessary to explain, same with Messiah since Christ is Meshika in the Peshita, and Rabbi is basically Aramaic in origin.  Now you might think that argument is hypocritical because of Revelation 9:11 identifying both a Hebrew and Greek name, but in that verse neither Name is used outside of being tied to it's language.  John says a Semitic word and then explains it in Greek.  The Peshita of John simply doesn't have the explanation in these verses which allows one to argue the translator added them, but our Greek of Matthew and Mark doesn't do that for "Messiah" or Peter's new name.  Matthew 1:23 is interpreting a name from Isaiah 7:14 that most Jews probably interpreted differently at first.  Mark 15:22 in the Peshita gives an Aramaic equivalent for the Hebrew Golgotha, likewise with Mark 15:34.

The Peshita of John 8 lacks the story of the Adulteress and for 1 John lacked it's declaration of The Trinity.  Disputed passages I plan to make defenses of in future posts on this blog.

Also, based on the little bit of Aramaic that pops up in the Hebrew Bible, I feel that Memar/Memra should be the Aramaic equivalent of Dabar and Logos.  But the key Logos verses in the Peshita of John use Miltha.  Though the emphasis some Peshita proponents make on Miltha being Feminine is interesting in light of another study I'm working on, Memra could just as easily be said in a Feminine form.

I haven't yet done enough research into the Peshita versions of texts I'm open to an Aramaic origin for.  So I'm cautious to in any way sound like I'm strongly endorsing it.

But one major issue is the Peshita lacks two of those books, 2 Peter and Jude.  2 Peter could have been written to Peter's usual audience rather then the specifically identified Greek audience of 1st Peter.  And it being originally in a different language could help explain why it seems to scholars like Peter's Epistles can't have the same author.  The name of Tartaros being in 2 Peter may be odd if it wasn't originally in Greek, but it could have mentioned a Mesopotamian equivalent.  The most possibly distinctly Greek detail in Jude is referring to "Wandering Stars" a Greek astronomical term, equivalents of which may have existed elsewhere but likely wouldn't translate to that directly.

One website on the subject of Semitic Origins for the New Testament I used to visit a lot is www.Ancient-Hebrew.org but I can't agree with everything there.

More recently is the Nazarene Judaism website.  It's a peculiar form of the Hebrew Roots movement that I've mentioned before.  Again I can't agree with them on everything.

On the subject of Aramaic Texts they side against the Peshita unlike me.  They are similar to me on the subject of existing Hebrew texts for Matthew however, except they are not quite as strongly anti Shem-Tov as I am.

The Shem-Tov is more like the Aramaic Targums of the Old Testament then a proper Hebrew version of Matthew.  I think the key to figuring out the original Hebrew of Matthew is the DuTillet, Muster and Cinuarbres manuscripts.  There is also a Muster text of Hebrews.

But again, I mention these with caution since I really can't study them directly and haven't read enough of what has been studied.  My strong support of the Textus Receptus over the Sinaticus, Vaticanus and Alexandrinus for the Greek texts still means that even books that might not have been originally in Greek were preserved well in the Textus Receptus.  Any difference in these Semitic texts that effects major doctrines I have to be very hesitant to accept.  Also the very same quotes from Eusebius about Clement saying Paul wrote Hebrews in Hebrew also say it was Luke who made the Greek translation, so in that context I trust Luke to have translated it right.

What I've heard about Hebrew Matthew's version of the "Eye of the Needle" expression, and Matthew 24 saying "The Last Generation" (saying  L'Dowr Acharown from Psalms 48, 78 and 102, which English Bibles usually don't translate accurately but Jewish ones will say "The Last Generation"), only help support how I already interpret those verses as they appear in the Greek.

I have a number of questions I'm curious about if anyone who does know a lot about them stumbles upon this.

1. Might the Hebrew Matthew references to Simon The Leper also agree with the Peshita saying Jar Maker?  Or maybe something else entirely?

2. Are all appearances of Aion/Aionios/Aionion some form of Olam in the Hebrew texts?  And can the Aramaic words used in the Peshita also mean Age/Eon?  The Aramaic Scriptures Website translated Eternal in the key Eternal verses but doesn't phonetically tell me what the Aramaic word was.

3. Similarly with the "Hell" words.  In this case I'm confident the true Hebrew should say Sheol for Hades and in some way identify the Valley of Hinomm where Gehenna appears. 

4. Which of the at least 5 different Hebrew words for "South" is used when Jesus calls the Queen of Sheba the Queen of the South?  If it's Teman, Yamin, or Yam that could further verify Sheba is in Yemen, but if it's Negev that would help how Velikvoskians use that verse.  If it's Darowm that wouldn't help clarify the issue at all, but Darowm is what I would half way expect of a Hebrew translation of the Greek.

5. Matthew 21:43, in the KJV "The kingdom of God shall be taken from you, and given to a nation bringing forth the fruits thereof." Other translations will sometimes render this "a fruitful nation".  British Israelists and Two Hosue Theologists often want to imagine Jesus said the name of Ephraim here, but Ephraim means "double fruit".  It may help a developing pet theory of mine if He said Ephratah but it's not something I want to build a vital doctrine on.  So do the Hebrew Matthew texts use either of those words here?

6. When Jesus says Ego Eimi in Matthew 14:7 ("It is I" in the KJV) is that Ehyeh (I Am) in the Hebrew manuscripts of Matthew?  I already know it's Ena-Na in the Peshita.

I may be editing this in the future to add more such questions.  New Questions would be added above this sentence not to the P.S. section.

P.S.  Hell in the Peshita?

For the Peshita on Gehenna I did verify it's transliterated as Gihana in all three Mark 9 verses.  While James 3:6 has simply dropped Gehnna out of it (the Greek refers to Fire of Gehenna but the Peshita just to fire).  Maybe an Aramaic Primacy supporter could theorize Gehenna got added to the Greek in James because of a marginal note connecting it to the Gehenna Fire of Matthew.  Is this verse of James one that's different in other Greek texts?

Hades doesn't appear in any books I consider plausible for Aramaic primacy, none the less it looks like The Peshita renders Hades as Sheul.

While Revelation isn't in the Peshita an Aramaic text of it has popped up that some think could represent an Aramaic Original.  A problem for an Aramaic origin for Revelation is in fact Revelation 9:11, clearly the Language of the book wouldn't be left out of that list of names?  Does this Aramaic Revelation add an Aramaic name like how some Catholic Bibles add Exterminans?  And does it say Sheul for Hades like the Peshita?

Update: I have learned that the Peshita, even the books I'm open to Aramaic primacy for, uses the Greek word Evangelion (rendered Evangeliun).  How do Peshita Primacy supporters explain that?

There was Greek presence in first century Mesopotamia, like the city of Seleucia which was always predominantly Greek.  So it's not impossible texts written there could have been written in Greek.  But also not impossible for some Greek to wind up in Aramaic texts written there.

2020 Update: So an issue with specifically Peshita Primacy is that's a specific dialect of Aramaic that is very Mesopotamian.  So of books I'm open to Aramaic Primacy for only 2 Peter and Mark originated in the part of the world where it would have been that form of Aramaic.  And 2 Peter isn't part of the preserved Peshita.  I have considered that maybe 1 Peter had both a Greek and Aramaic form given the broad range of regions it was directed to.

For Mark the appearance of the word Evangeliun in the first verse of the Peshita is evidence that text is a translation.  However that is specifically a Latin for of the word Euangelion, and some have argued for Mark being originally written in Latin, and Latin texts do use forms of Evangelion.  So maybe the Peshita version of Mark is a translation of a Latin text?

Thursday, August 9, 2018

Do Universalists need to throw out certain books of The Bible?

I just found a website attacking Universal Salvation that acknowledges the Antiochian School taught it, and then says.
It was not without reason that the Antioch School refused to canonize the books of II Peter, II and III John, Jude and Revelation. The doctrine of the Universal Salvation could be easily refuted by these five books which contained so many verses on eternal judgment as to render them irrepressible:
I'm a proponent of Universal Salvation who is not at all afraid of these books.  The very verses from Jude they go on to cite are cited by me to prove "Eternal Fire" can't mean endless torment in both KJV Universal Salvation and Words Translated Eternal, because it's used of the fire that destroyed Sodom and in Ezekiel 16 Yahuah promises Sodom will be restored.  And I recently wrote a blog post on how Revelation points to Universal Salvation, and addressed The Lake of Fire in my posts on Gehenna and the Baptism of Fire.

As far as second Peter goes, they cited two verses referring to Judgment on Sinners, none inherently saying it'll be endless or even Aionion.  God's punishments are for Correction (Habakkuk 1:12 and Proverbs 3:11) and not endless (Matthew 5:26, Luke 12:59 and Matthew 18:34).  And again one of them was about Sodom and Gomorrah, which again we know will be restored because of Ezekiel 16.  2 Peter 3:9 is one of my favorite Universal Salvation proof texts, he says God is "not willing" that any should perish.

They didn't even cite anything from II or III John, those short books deal with Believers behaving badly which makes them attractive to those who say Salvation can be lost or that we need to be on guard for fake believers.  But nothing in those books refers to endless torment or annihilation as being their Punishment.  In III John it's clear the bad Christian we're to be concerned about is the one trying to kick others out.

This came up later in an article mainly opposing the Semitic New Testament theory, since the Aramaic Peshita lacks exactly the books listed above, and the Church of the East emerged largely from the Antiochene School.  I mostly agree with them that the original Language of most of The New Testament was Greek, I'm going to be doing a post on that in the near future.

They accuse Universal Salvation of being Gnostic by associating it with Clement, Origen and Diodore.  But they left out Gregory of Nyssa.  The Predestination doctrine of Augustine is what was condemned as Gnostic Hersey by the Pre-Nicene fathers, both Origen and Methodius of Olympus (who on many other issues disagreed with Origen) wrote books on the subject.

This website decided to just accept the worst slanders against Nesotrius and Theodore of Mopsuestia uncritically.  Theodore did NOT teach a from of Adoptionism, he wrote whole books on the Incarnation.

At any rate dispute on some of these books existed already before Nicaea, it used to be opponents of Pre-Millenial Eschatology just rejected Revelation altogether, like Eusebius of Caesarea, it was Augustine who enabled them to allegorize it away.

The Muratorian Fragment fails to mentions Either of Peter's Epistles or James or Hebrews and apparently includes only two of John's.  But it did include Jude.  And it adds the Apocalypse of Peter which affirms Universal Salvation.

I doubt this website approves of the Book of Enoch being added to the Canon, which I mention because the ancient arguments against Jude's inclusion were because it seemingly quotes Enoch.  So no, it being a problem for Universal Salvation was not the reason.

I do support the 27 Book New Testament as preserved by the Textus Receptus.  I just pointed out these facts to provide some context showing that Universal Salvation could not have been the issue.

Some of my allies give Enoch part of the blame for the development of the Endless Torment doctrine.  But while I definitely don't consider Enoch Canon, I do consider what it says about the fate of Azazel and his armies consistent with how I interpret the nature of the Lake of Fire.
 And he said unto me, “These are being prepared for the armies of Azazel, in order that they may take them and cast them into the abyss of complete condemnation, and as the Lord of the Spirits has commanded it, they shall cover their jaws with rocky stones. Then Michael, Raphael, Gabriel, and Phanuel themselves shall seize them on that great day of judgment and cast them into the furnace (of fire) that is burning that day, so that the Lord of the Spirits may take vengeance on them on account of their oppressive deeds which (they performed) as messengers of Satan, leading astray those who dwell upon the earth.”
It said "on account of their deeds" meaning the Punishment will fit the Crime.  Meanwhile the first 8 verses of the Book sound pretty Universalist.

In Richard Laurence's Translation "for ever" must be a bad translation (or the Ethiopic was a poor translation).   Chapter 10 Verse 8 describes a condition as "for ever" that the very next verse says will one day end.  And then verse 15 says "till the judgment that will last forever be completed"???????.  Repeatedly the imprisonment of the Angels is said to be "for ever" even though it's also defined as 70 Generations.

Enoch 22:13-14 is what most seemingly opposes Universal Salvation in the book.  But it is also a big problem for those who want to make it Canon, it explicitly says the Souls of Sinners won't rise from where they currently are on the day of judgment, this is explicitly contradicted by Revelation 20, 1 Corinthians 15, John 5 and Daniel 12.   It might be possible to argue all Jude was even vaguely endorsing was the first part of the book and not this later proto-Dante's Inferno.  Or this could be another textual corruption or translation issue and that verse meant to say their souls won't be destroyed or released from their prison until the Day of Judgment.

Origen was pretty fine with Enoch even though we know he supported a form of Universal Salvation.

Friday, April 6, 2018

The Heresies of Asia Minor

I'm annoyed by people appealing to the Early Church Fathers as if a doctrine being affirmed by them from very early on must make it valid, because The New Testament informs us heresies were emerging already in the first generation of The Church.

In Acts 20:16 Paul arrived in Ephesus and proceeded to warn them about false teachers who will emerge as soon as he leaves them.  Verses 29-31.
"For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.  Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them.  Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears."
And later in 2 Timothy 1:15 Paul laments that all of Asia has departed from him.

In Revelation 2:2 the Ephesian Church being addressed is commended for rejecting False Apostles.  But the same false doctrines Ephesus resisted here we can infer were not so well resisted by the other churches, especially Pergamos.  Jesus refused to say anything bad about Smyrna because they were dying for their Faith, but even martyrs can be influenced by bad doctrines.

Now the Anti-Paul people insist Revelation is on the other side of this conflict, that Paul and his Clique are the False Apostles Jesus refereed to.  After all Paul said "All of Asia" seemingly not allowing Ephesus as an exception.

The Bible will sometimes use the word "all" hyperbolically when exceptions do exist.  That Ephesus is where Paul gave the warning, and also the only of the Seven Churches to also be recipients of a Paulian Epistle, is sufficient reason to expect them to be the exception.  Also Timothy himself was a Bishop in Ephesus when these letters were written so clearly he represents some support Paul still had there.

Meanwhile it could be a specific Church in Ephesus that John was in contact with being addressed.  It can be inferred that Ephesus is the city these False Apostles were operating in and that's why they're relevant to that message.

However it's also interesting that Jesus addresses them as the "Church of Ephesus" not the "Church in ____" as he did 5 of the 6 following Churches.  Could it be that the true Ephesian Church Paul founded was not actually in Ephesus anymore?  Remember he met with them as Miletus once.

I should mention that different definitions of what "Asia" meant in these kinds of contexts can create ambiguity about if Phyrgian locations (like Laodicea and the recipients of Colossians and maybe Philadephia) count as Asia. Some texts of 1 Timothy end with Paul saying he wrote that letter in Laodicea.  1 Peter 1:1 by not mentioning Phrygia at all is probably counting it as Asia, but language in Acts 16 seems to imply neither Phrygia or Mysia (where Pergamon was) count as Asia.  The Roman Province of Asia included all Seven cities however.  Polycrates seems to be counting Phrygian locations like Hierapolis and Laodicea as Asia, but since Pergamon and Thyatira aren't mentioned we don't know if he'd count them.

I think the more specific use of Asia is treating it as a synonym for Lydia (but with Coastal cities like Miletus, Ephesus and Smyrna added), which The Bible never uses as a location name, but in Acts 16 a woman from Thyatira is called Lydia in the KJV but the Greek means Lydian(of Lydia).  Thyatira was on the border between Lydia and Mysia.  Sardis was the capital of Ancient Lydia and the seat of a Proconsul under Rome.

I talked about the Apostles of Ephesus on this blog before, in that post mostly accepting the traditions at face value.  But now, given this direct Biblical Evidence of False Apostles in Ephesus, I should perhaps be just as skeptical of the traditions about John and the Marys going to Ephesus as I am of Peter going to Rome.  My theory that traditions of Mary Magdelene going to France are derivative of earlier traditions of her going to Ephesus because of Ephesian Christians migrating to France remains valid however.

It's interesting then how much of the alleged "Apostolic Succession" of the Early Church Fathers goes back to Asia Minor.  Polycarp, Ignatius and presumably Papias were all direct students of a "John" who was in Ephesus in the late first century.  Students of Polycarp founded the early church of Lyon in France, one of whom Irenaus was the mentor of Hipolytus an early Bishop of Rome and only Early Church precedent for Dispensationalist interpretations of Daniel 9 and 11.  Ignatius who is given much of the credit for the development of Early Church Hierarchy was a Bishop of Antioch so also played a role in spreading these doctrines beyond Asia Minor.

The Montanists also had their origin in Asia Minor, and were an influence on Tertulian the first Church Father to write in Latin and thus a major influence on later Latin Church writers like Augustine. 

Marcian also first emerged in Asia Minor.  Now at face value he's the opposite of departing from Paul, Marcian was Paul's biggest super fan.  But we see in 1 Corinthians that Paul was also annoyed by people saying they are "Of Paul" he would not like the term "Paulian Christianity".  Paul's warning in Acts 20 was of multiple heresies not just one, some emerging from without and some emerging from within.

Frankly the reason why so much confusion exists about the Nicolatians is because people keep turning to the Early Church Fathers opinions to identify them when in my view they were the Nicolatians and so in constant denial about who the Nicolatians really were and what they taught.

What Papias is quoted as saying about John The Presbyter I view as evidence that the original John of Ephesus was not an authentic Biblical John, but that his followers confused him with John later.

The canonocity of 2 John and 3 John were sometimes disputed in the Early Church.  Including attributing them to John the Presbyter.  But that early dispute gave them the same author, some today think these two Epistles were actually condemning each others authors.  That 3 John's description of Diotrephes fits the author of 2 John like a glove.  And so likewise the author of 3 John could be one of the people 2 John complains about.  Neither text actually identifies itself as having been written by a John.

But assuming they have the same Author, they still both show heretics had emerged within the presumed Johnian community.

Diotrephes has been seen as the first Monarchial Bishop.  Some early Church references do imply that in Asia Paul's Churches had many Elders who were all Bishops while Churches founded by "John" had one Bishop and multiple elders, a Structure elaborated upon by his student Ignatius.  So whether he wrote 2 John or not I think Diotrephes which means "nourished by Zeus" could be a name for the false John of Ephesus.

The origins of identifying the Beloved Disciple with the name of John are partly based on Polycrates statements about the John of Ephesus who he doesn't say was one of the 12.  He does say this John was a Priest (as in Kohen not as in Presbytr) possibly specifically a High Priest since he wore the Sacredotal Plate.  There was a High Priest of the Jerusalem Temple in the First Century named John, he was one of the sons of Ananias and probably the John kindred to the High Priest mentioned in Acts 4.  He served as High Priest twice both very briefly and we don't know what became of him afterwards.

Crenthius was one of the earliest Proto-Gnostics, and he spent time in Asia Minor.  Some also speculate he specifically was among those John's Epistles were written against.   What's distinct about Crenthius is that while Gnostic in many ways including separating the Demiurge from The Father.  He didn't view the Demiurge as Evil but rather taught we still had to follow The Law of Moses.  In a way that makes him a lot like Rob Skiba, who's an ardent Hebrew Roots believer but believes a lot of quasi Gnostic stuff.

The claim that Crenthius's Gospel was a version of Matthew I think must be wrong.  His doctrines make much more sense if he was focusing on Mark.  In fact I now think his Hersey was the origin of removing the last portion of Mark 16.

Melito the Eunuch who fell asleep in Sardis was also someone who seems to have had Legalistic tendencies.  The heresies Paul warned of I think are likely to include falling back into Legalism, after all the Ravening Wolves imagery suggests some of these false teachers will be fellow Benjamites based on Genesis 49.

This does not mean Asia Minor was the only source of Hersey.  Simon Magus I still believe was the real Peter of Rome, Justin Martyr was another mystic from Samaria who started his own school in Rome, and Tatian (possibly the first to teach Endless Torment and other Gnostic ideas) was a student of his. Justin was an early example of seeking to justify claiming that Socrates and Plato taught Christian ideas because they were in contact with the Logos.

I'm not trying to demonize anyone.  Some of the people I mentioned in this post were Martyred for their Faith in Jesus, and for that I firmly believe they won the Crown of Life no matter how flawed their doctrines were.  My point is simply that being an early belief of The Church doesn't make it a correct one.

There is a website called Church-History.Org which has some good information on it, but it says that Protestants were right to reject the Catholic Understanding of Tradition and Apostolic succession but were wrong to reject "Apostolic Tradition".   The problem is this Apostolic Tradition becomes exactly the same thing as the "Oral Torah" of Rabbinic Judaism aka The Pharisees Jesus preached against.  And it cites Ignatius as proof monarchical Church structure isn't heretical while admitting it's not supported by Scripture.

All references in the New Testament to "traditions" that seem positive are to teachings that became written down in the New Testament.  You need to remember when Paul was writing not even all 4 Gospels had been written down yet, and most of his Epistles predate Luke-Acts which were written while he was in Rome.  One of the things Jude refers to as a teaching from the Apostles is written down in 2 Peter, which some scholars think was written later then Jude.  But for the most part these "traditions" are what Jesus taught in The Gospels and what Peter and John taught in the first 11 chapters of Acts.

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

The Books of Chronicles versus Samuel and Kings

When it comes to skeptics looking for alleged Bible Contradictions, The Book (they were one book originally) of Chronicles providing an alternate account of the History of the Kingdom Period is perhaps second only to the parallel Gospel record.

I do feel there are no irreconcilable differences in terms of what the two accounts say happened. I've already talked about The Widow's Son and Jehosheba.  And the Genealogy of Rehoboam's Queen in a Song of Songs post.  As far as whether David used Silver or Gold to buy the land of the threshing floor, the accounts are specific in what they say, the Gold bought the land itself and the Silver everything on the land.

What my mind has been contemplating is a pretty clear thematic difference in point of view.  The Gospels have different things they emphasize, but never leading to the conclusion they are trying to send a totally different message.  With Chronicles it does sometimes seem that way.

We can view these as different points of view where one is less correct then the other, without completely rejecting either as part of God's Word.  It may be God wants us to know and learn from this other POV. 2 Timothy 2:15 talks about rightly dividing the word of truth.  We often talk about needing two witnesses to build doctrine, but don't fully think about the implications of when there isn't a confirming witness.

The first apparent example of this is the origin of the Samaritans.

2 Kings 17 tells us Assyria after deporting seemingly all of the Northern Kingdom settled some people from Northern Mesopotamia in their old land.  The newcomers worshiped their old idols which caused problems, then Assyria gives them a Priest of Jeroboam's Priesthood who teaches them to worship Jeroboam's Idols.  Later in 2 Kings 23:15 Josiah destroys the altar at Bethel which ends Idolatry in the region.  But the point still remains that the Samaritans descend from foreigners.

2 Chronicles does not contain it's own version of the 2 Kings 17 narratives, it does refer to Josiah destroying idols but doesn't single out Bethel.  However in chapter 30 we learn that some remnants of the northern kingdom's population were still there during the reign of Hezekiah who invited them to his Passover celebration.  Some mocked the invitation, but others accepted, with people of Manasseh and Ephraim being mentioned in both groups.  Now the text of 2 Chronicles isn't explicitly saying this is where the Samaritans come from, but the implication could to be they come from those who rejected it.

Now these accounts can both be perfectly true, in fact both being true fits best what the Assyrian inscriptions say, they didn't deport everyone just a lot, this policy was about mixing their population.

But the point is Kings and Chronicles choose different things to emphasize.  And on this thematic disagreement, the New Testament takes a side. 

When Jesus sent the 70 Disciples on their first training missionary mission, He tells them to go only to the Children of Israel and not Gentiles or Samaritans, showing he didn't count them as Israelites.  Later at the true Great Commission the Samaritans are included as are the gentiles.  (Ezra and Nehemiah also seem to confirm the Kings viewpoint.)  

[Update May 9th 2026: I've since changed my mind entirely about 2 Kings 17's relevance to the Samaritans.]

Matthew's genealogy uses the final form of the name of Salmon that Ruth uses, not Salma from 1 Chronicles 2.

One might argue Matthew not including King Manasseh among the generations skipped is an influence of Chronicles, since only Chronicles records his repentance, based on Kings alone you'd think he's the worst most irredeemable villain of the Kingdom Period.  Bur he's not the only Bad King who's name is still included.

And 1 Chronicles 2 may be the only basis for putting a Recab in David's genealogy (Matthew is not saying Rahab the Harlot married Salmon, her name is Raab in New Testament texts).  But that's about it for possible New Testament dependence on Chronicles, one genealogy which for at least one name is also going against Chronicles.

The only point where a New Testament author can be made to look like they're directly quoting  Chronicles, is really them and Chronicles quoting the same Davidic Psalm.  Of course that is true of apparent New Testament quotations of Samuel as well.  And the only NT quotes of Kings is of Elijah speaking.  Jesus quoted The Torah and Prophets (Acts 2 calls David a Prophet), but it can maybe be argued that the New Testament doesn't want us to take the histories in the Kingdom period books at entirely face value.

The Chronicles account is also responsible for much of the confusion about Tarshish.  The only verses making it sound like Tarshish was the destination of naval adventures from the Red Sea port are in 2 Chronicles in 9:21 and 20:36-37.  Their equivalent passages in 1 Kings 10:11&22 and 2 Kings 22:48 make clear that Ophir in Yemen was the destination, but the ships are called ships of Tarshish because they were modeled after Tarshish ships, possibly with cooperation from Tarshish.

This may not be entirely wrong, looking at things like how Native Americans became Indians, maybe at some point Israelites started calling this place Tarshish even though it really wasn't because that's what they called the ships they used to get there.  But Jonah makes clear that Tarshish is really accessed via the the Mediterranean port at Joppa. 

But this confusion has been useful for people who don't find the mainstream views of Tarshish romantic enough, wanting to make it Briton, or Atlantis, or India, or Japan, and I'd even contemplated making them the Olmecs in the past.  But I've abandoned those speculations now.

What's even more interesting is Solomon.  Chronicles has no equivalent to 1 Kings 11.  Which is the first of a few facts suggesting it has a generally more apologetic attitude towards Solomon.  And returning to the subject of the New Testament taking sides, I did a post on how the New Testament is rather dismissive of Solomon.

By leaving out the murder of Urias and including the repentance of Manasseh, Chronicles is arguably being more apologetic to the Davidic Kings in general.  But the moral point is David and Manasseh repented, Solomon never repented of his 1 Kings 11 sins.

1 Kings 4 tells us Solomon went to Sacrifice at the "Great High Place" at Gibeon, elsewhere Kings consistently refers to High Places as inherently bad. Many commentators on this say it shows God's mercy that he answers Solomon's prayer here in-spite of this, and I can't say I exactly disagree with that.

But when 2 Chronicles 1 records the same event, it also identifies Gibeon and calls it a High Place, but adds that this was where the Tabernacle of Moses was.  Other passages in the books of Chronicles further back up the Tabernacle being here for awhile.  But Samuel and Kings never place the Tabernacle at Gibeon, they don't contradict it being here at this time, and do earlier place it at Nob (in an event Jesus refers to) which is often speculated to be either close by or another name for the same place.  But the tone in Kings seems to be that Solomon was in error coming here, while Chronicles wants to justify it.  And Kings tells us Abiathar the priest who survived the Nob massacre lived at Anathoth, and that Abiathar later was working with Joab and Adonijah in their attempted coup, another story Chronicles leaves out.

In fact Samuel-Kings also links a Great Stone at Gibeon to Absalom and Amasa's rebellion.

Even if the physical Tabernacle built by Moses was there, it was violating the Torah itself by being on a High Place.  And also the Ark wasn't here, it was brought by David to first Zion and then Jerusalem.  Psalm 132 tells us David's Tabernacle was at Ephratha.

And then there is how only 2 Chronicles 3:1 applies the name of Moriah to where Ornan's threshing floor was and where Solomon's Temple was built.  Again this Moriah could be not the same hill as Genesis 22:2 and still not be wrong, Solomon may have given the name of Moriah to the hill to evoke that event.

Friday, November 24, 2017

Torah as The Foundation of The Canon

A few posts I've made over the last two months have been addressed to people who's view on Canon I've described as "Torah Only".  The Remember The Commands YouTube channel rejects that description it seems, preferring to say it's the Torah as the Foundation.

Thing is it's basically the same thing, when you're using an extreme interpretation of the Prophet Test to discredit any book that has any apparent conflict with The Torah.  But of course they have a different attitude towards alleged places where The Torah contradicts itself.

Numbers 12:6-8 is cited as explaining why Moses is distinct from other Prophets, why what Moses said and wrote is more Canon then anything else.

But Deuteronomy 18:15-19 foretells a future Prophet like Moses, who's authority will be exactly like how Moses was described in Numbers 12.

I believe that Prophet was Jesus.  That belief requires a great deal of Faith, as does placing one's Faith in the God of Moses.  So anything Jesus quoted as Scripture must be Scripture, and He also passed on His authority to the 12, starting with Peter.  And Peter called Paul's writings Scripture.

It's interesting in the context of this title of Jesus to remember what Exodus 7:1 says.  Typologically that's another place where Moses represents Jesus, and Aaron all New Testament believers, since now we are all Priests.

Basically what I'm saying is, to Christians Jesus is our Cornerstone, and His Apostles who wrote the New Testament are our Foundation.   The dispensation of The Torah is over.

Update November 25th 2017:

Some who aren't Christians or Rabbinic Jews seek to deconstruct the whole idea of Messianic Prophecy.  They might insist that Deuteronomy 18 wasn't meant to be about a single individual.   But that it would be an office.

Meanwhile the context in Numbers 12 is Yahuah explaining why Miriam and Aaron' authority are not like that of Moses.  So you can argue the intent was only that while Moses lived no one else's authority equals Moses.

The end of Deuteronomy does clearly say there was no one like Moses during whatever time separated it's authorship from the Death of Moses.  However....

When you look at Samuel's story in 1st Samuel 3, it's easy to conclude that perhaps that author meant us to think of Samuel as the Prophet like Unto Moses, and he was contemporary with other events foretold in Deuteronomy, in chapter 17.  Samuel is often considered the first Prophet in the sense of how that Office functioned during the Kingdom period.  And most of the Prophetic books are arguably defining themselves as being like how Moses is defined in these passages of Numbers and Deuteronomy, with only Daniel fitting Numbers 12's description of the not Moses like Prophets.

This view can be reconciled with the Christian view.  The Prophet like unto Moses is ultimately Jesus, but other Prophets foreshadowed Him, and then He passed His Authority onto The Apostles.

Wednesday, November 15, 2017

The Offices of Apostle and Prophet

The New Testament offices of Apostle and Prophet are not the same, they are distinct.

I am a Continuationist, the Spiritual Gifts are for today, one of those is Prophecy.

An Apostle is something more specific.  Chris White has a good video on Apostolic Succession directed at Catholic Doctrine.
Thing is other versions of that doctrine have been utilized by non Catholic denominations.  I already did a post once on the Baptist version of it some Baptists believe.

This post is partly about a problem I've noticed of some Pentecostal and Charismatic Christian Leaders calling themselves Apostle.  Paul defined himself as the Last Apostle (1 Corinthians 15:8-9), and made clear you had to be an eye witness to the Resurrection to be an Apostle in the verses leading up to that.  Acts 1 agrees that being an eye witness was a requirement for being an Apostle.

Critics of Continuationism sometimes assert that the Canon isn't closed if there is still Prophecy, and some Contuionationists seem to effectively teach that.  But prophecy has to be tested against Scripture, and I believe only Apostles could add to Scripture.  In order for something to be Scripture it had to be written by an Apostle or approved by one.

I've seen some Ceasationists use Apostle and Prophet as if they are the same.  But The New Testament clearly treats them as distinct.  There are some passages where you can cite that verse alone and say maybe they're being used as synonyms there.  And in a sense I think every Apostle was a Prophet.   But verses like 1 Corinthians 12:28 clearly define them as distinct.

I can't currently think of a Hebrew word that might equate to what Apostle means in the New Testament.  But in concept I can point to Numbers 12 which distinguishes between the authority of Moses and that of other Prophets.  Jesus was the Prophet like Moses and He gave His Mosaic authority to the Apostles.

Some of the people who want to reject Paul act like Paul's claim to Apostolic status makes him a 13th Apostle, or in some way the only one additional to the 12.  But that's clearly not what Paul said in 1 Corinthians 15, placing James the Half-Brother of Jesus and many others between the 12 and himself as the last.  Acts 14:14 says Paul and Barnabas were both Apostles.  In Romans 16 Paul identifies as an Apostle a woman seemingly not named anywhere else in Scripture named Junia (though there's a theory she's the same woman as Joanna in Luke's Gospel).

Peter calls Paul's writings Scripture at the end of 2 Peter.  People try to argue around this fact, but it's undeniable.

I bring this up because the Anti-Paul people often desire to limit the title of Apostle only to the 12 (with Matthias taking Judas's spot).  Yet they try to get around the full implication that that would remove canonical status from at least 2 of the Gospels.  And that they may have to throw out James and Jude too if you believe the tradition that they were written by Half-Brothers of Jesus not the James son of Alpheius and Jude "Not Iscariot" of the 12.  And they frequently use James in their attacks on Paul.

Ironically for all this James vs Paul theorizing nonsense, it is only Paul who tells us James the Brother of Jesus qualified as an Apostle. Without him, we'd have no direct Biblical basis for believing that James ever became a Believer at all.  The James of the Acts 15 council I believe was the surviving James of the 12, not Jesus' brother.

Saturday, November 11, 2017

How do Torah only people determine what is The Torah?

People like the Remember the Commands YouTube Channel keep saying things like "The Torah never told us to recognize the Canon of Jamnia, or the Calvanists".  My response is....

How do you know the Torah is what we today think it is?  Nothing in The Torah defines it as Five Books of Moses, one of which is actually a historical narrative of events that happened before Moses was born, so traditionally saying Moses wrote it kinda hurts seeing it as an eye witness account of that history.  And another is a book Moses couldn't have physically wrote himself since it records his death.

Now Deuteronomy can be called a "Book of Moses" since it's mostly a record of Speeches Moses gave, so quoting it for the most part is quoting Moses.... IF it's an authentic account.

Only Deuteronomy refers to there being a "Book of Law" in that exact phrase.   You can interpret those verses as implying what your reading now is part of that book, but that's kinda iffy.  It seems equally likely it's referring to a book already written.

Why would a book of Laws also include all these historical narratives?  Well there being commands to remember things seemingly makes the historical narratives part of the Law.  But still, one could easily argue that The Torah proper is just what God gave to Moses on Mount Sinai.

Exodus 20:22 begins the proper Covenant Law Code, which arguably concludes in Exodus 24:4, this was written in a Scroll by Moses.  But Exodus 25:1 through 31:17 are seemingly what is defined as being written in Stone, according to 31:18.  The Stones had to be carved again after the Golden Calf incident.  But Exodus 34:28 says the second set of Tablets were written by Moses dictated by Yahuah not by the Finger of Yahuah like the first Tablets were. 

Leviticus is stuff added later, as are the parts of Numbers that are new commands, they don't even define themselves as part of either the original Scroll of Moses or what was written in Stone.  Deuteronomy meanwhile, doesn't even pass it's own Prophet Test by the standards of how Remember the Commands interprets things.  But even if presumed to be a valid record of Speeches Moses gave at the end of the wandering, it mostly demonstrates that Moses memory was often faulty, even the Ten Commandments are expressed differently.

I'm certain Deuteronomy is Canon, since I think anything Jesus quoted as Scripture must be Scripture, and Jesus quoted Deuteronomy 6 for what He called the Greatest Commandment.  In fact Deuteronomy is the most quoted book of The Torah in the New Testament, with even some NT references to the Ten Commandments seemingly preferring Deuteronomy's version.  Jesus also quotes Genesis, Exodus and Leviticus, and allusions are made to events from Numbers.

Thing is, I think it's fairly illogical to accept Deuteronomy as Canon but not Joshua.  I think Deuteronomy and Joshua's scrolls mostly had the same human author, much of Deuteronomy seems like it's written there just to set the stage for Joshua.

Friday, November 10, 2017

The Prophet Test of Deuteronomy

Most websites I find online talking about the Prophet Test of Deuteronomy in relation to Jonah, Jeremiah or Ezekiel, are doing so assuming the readers will not question the Prophetic Status of those three Prophets, and so we must interpret Deuteronomy in a way that is consistent with them being valid Prophets.  These sites being Continuationist Christians seeking to defend modern Pentecostal/Charismatic Prophets against attempts to use Deuteronomy to discredit them.

But I have become aware of a growing Torah only movement, or at least heavily Torah centric, that would rather reject Prophets of the TNAK as true Prophets then change their overly strict "Plain Reading" interpretation of Deuteronomy.  To them it's blasphemous to use Jeremiah 18 to interpret Deuteronomy 18, they would say Jeremiah 18 was Jeremiah making excuses for himself.

Jonah, Jeremiah (and possibly Ezekiel) are all upheld as Prophets by the New Testament.  So as a Christian I need to defend them as legit Prophets.

What Jeremiah says Yahuah said in Jeremiah 18 is absolutely consistent with The Torah, the Torah repeatedly teaches that God's Blessings and Curses are conditioned upon behavior.  In fact Deuteronomy's prophecy in chapters 29 and 30 is entirety couched as a hypothetical.

This website teaches plenty I disagree with, like on Ezekiel and Tyre which I'll get to later.  But it's an analysis on the Prophet test of Deuteronomy that I think is over all pretty helpful.
http://www.crivoice.org/prophetdeut18.html

What's deemed a capital offense is prophesying in the name of other gods, or saying it's okay to worship other gods. That is what it's most concerned with.  Deuteronomy 18:22 says.
"When a prophet speaketh in the name of Yahuah, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which Yahuah hath not spoken, but the prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him."
It doesn't say this Prophet wasn't a true Believer, or even that he never was a true Prophet.  But he spoke presumptuously and for that reason you should no longer fear his words.  But it doesn't call for execution.  In English in the KJV it looks like this Prophet would also be guilty of Deuteronomy 18:20's offense, but clearly there is a difference.

Interestingly some offshoots of Mormonism like Temple Lot teach that Josephus Smith was a true Prophet at first, but eventually went bad and spoke presumptuously.  I think the very foundation of what Joseph Smith taught from the start had major inconsistencies with Scripture, but it's interesting to note that some Mormons look at things that way.

As a Continuationist Christian, I think it's important to note that 1 John 4:2-3 says "Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God: And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God".  There is no room for exceptions to either of those declarations.  Likewise 1 John 5:1 "Whosoever believeth that Jesus is the Christ is born of God".

Now, I disagree whole heartedly with the assertion that Ezekiel's Prophecy of Tyre failed.  Or that we need to expand it's time-frame to include Alexander to make it not a failure (I believe Isaiah 23's Prophecy about Tyre is specifically of Alexander's conquest, where Kittim/Greece is mentioned).

First of all, there is an accusation that Ezekiel 29:17-20 is some kind of admission that his Prophecy about Tyre failed.  This is not the case.  God is saying Nebuchadnezzar and his army performed a service for him by sieging Tyre, and so he's giving him Egypt to reward that service.  Strictly speaking we do not know whether that Siege was successful based on Ezekiel 29 alone.

Now some might infer that if sieging Tyre was successful they wouldn't need to capture another country to be paid for it.  A, plenty of successful sieges have failed to produce booty, like when Xerxes captured Athens.  B, I can counter that if no judgment was inflicted on Tyre, they performed no service to be paid for.

People are reading things into Ezekiel 26 that aren't there when they say Nebuchadnezzar had to capture the Island to fulfill the Prophecy.  What people ignore criticizing this Prophecy is the origin of the Island becoming the main city was the people fleeing there during this Siege, and that is what Ezekiel is describing.  The Mainland city is all Ezekiel is clearly saying will be destroyed.

And as far as saying the not being inhabited part is a failure because Tyre exists to this day.  That is false, there is a city in New Testament and modern times calling itself Tyre, but that doesn't make it Tyre, it was not built on the exact same location.  The mainland city Nebuchadnezzar destroyed is still a barren ruin right now.

Now one could say Alexander's actions have some relevance because of how he threw many of the ruins of the old city into the sea as he built his land bridge.  But that is a minor epilogue.

Now as far as questioning if Nebuchadnezzar ever captured Egypt.   I talked about that on my Prophecy blog.

But going back to the conditional commands.  As far as some people who might fear I'm weakening the Prophet Test's usefulness in opposing cults.  The conditional aspect is only an excuse if a nation wide change in behavior happens.

Thursday, November 9, 2017

New Testament quotes of and refrences to The Old Testament.

The "Sola Scriptura" tag of this Blog has a spent a lot of time justifying my rejection of the Canonicity of certain books.  Perhaps it's time I treated this blog with a similar attitude to my Blog where I talk about my opinions on modern fiction, where I prefer to defend what I like rather then attack what I don't.

I have already said some things addressing those who limit Canon to the Torah, or to the words of Jesus.  In particular where that involves a desire to reject Paul.  And will likely be returning to those subjects in the future.

But this post is more addressing those who may want to use NT quotes to determine what is or isn't valid in the OT Canon.

This article says there are ten books of the Old Testament never directly quoted in The New Testament. 
  1. Judges

  2. Ruth

  3. Ezra

  4. Esther

  5. Ecclesiastes

  6. Song of Solomon

  7. Lamentations

  8. Obadiah

  9. Jonah

  10. Zephaniah

They explain this is limited to direct quotes, where the context defines it as a quote.  And doesn't include allusions or parallel wording.  As such Revelation, which is built entirely on Old Testament allusions but has no direct quotes by this standard.  This author does not argue these books aren't Canon for this reason, it's simply a fact they are pointing out.

I used to follow Alan Krushner who did a whole thing on Ecclesiastes including New Testament allusions to it.  I agree that Romans 8 could maybe be viewed as thematically a summery.  But I feel a possibly overlooked direct reference is in Ecclesiastes 12:11.
"The words of the wise are as goads, and as nails fastened by the masters of assemblies, which are given from one shepherd."
Most people think when Jesus says "it is hard for thee to kick against the goads/pricks" when he called Saul latter known as Paul, he was quoting Euripides play Bacchants.  (Or skeptics would say Luke was quoting it) but this is actually a common expression, the only think that references from Acts has in common with that Greek play is it being in Plural when it's usually said singularly.  But still, if the intent was to quote that play I'd expect more of it's context to be included.  I feel like this verse from Ecclesiastes provides a decent Biblical precedent for using this expression.  The full quote from Euripides is "Why dost thou continue tor age and kick against the goads, a man against a god?".

Ruth is mentioned by name in the genealogy of Jesus given in Matthew 1.  Ruth's name is only in the Hebrew Bible in the book of Ruth, the genealogical information given about David in places like 1 Chronicles mention her husband, son and grandson, Boaz, Obed and Jesse, but not her.  So clearly the book of Ruth was a source of information Matthew was using.  Also the spelling Matthew and Luke used for Salmon comes from Ruth, Chronicles spells it Salma.

Jonah is referenced in some of the most famous of Jesus' references to the Old Testament.  Referring to three days and nights in the belly of the Whale, and referring to the men of Nineveh as gentiles who believed.

It is Lamentations 1:9&16 that provides the Old Testament basis for Comforter as a title of God or the Messiah, (The Talmud quotes it as a justification for Menahem being a name for the Messiah).  John's Gospel and first Epistle use this title of both Jesus and The Holy Spirit, though it being of the Holy Spirit is the most well known reference.

This page on a different site confuses me a bit.  It is clearly using a different standard then the above article, yet I still can't make sense of it.  It says there are only five books the NT doesn't quote Ezra, Nehemiah, Esther, Ecclesiastes, and the Song of Solomon.  They say they aren't less Canon because of that.  The thing is, the chart of quotations it then provides, fails to list any from Joshua, Judges, Ruth, Obadiah, Zephaniah or Nahum.

References to the person of Joshua son of Nun are not quite proof of that book being considered canon or even a source the person referencing him knew, since Joshua son of Nun appears in The Torah (and is referenced at the beginning of Judges).  It is Hebrews and James mentioning the story of Rahab the Harlot that I find to be the blatant evidence that New Testament authors used Joshua as a source of information.  The narrative surrounding the fall of Ai I think is thematically echoed in the Death, Burial and Resurrection of Jesus as well as the Sixth Seal in Revelation 6.

However the only basis for a direct quote of the book of Joshua in Scripture is Hebrews 13:5 referencing Joshua 1:5.  But that itself was of Joshua referencing back to Deuteronomy.

 People from the book of Judges are also mentioned in Hebrews.

Ya know what should really shock all these "The Torah is The Bible of The Bible" types?  Numbers is never quoted by Jesus and barely in the New Testament at all.  By the standards of the author of the first article for a clear quotation, only Numbers 9:12 is quoted in John 19:36, but that is only Numbers repeating something from Exodus 12.  According to the second link provided, the only reference to Numbers in the Gospels is 27:17 which is paraphrased by the narrative voice in Matthew 9:36, and then Numbers 16 is referenced in 2 Timothy 2:19.

When Jesus references the Brazen Serpent is a pretty solid reference to Numbers.  Balaam also comes up in Jude and the letters to the 7 Churches.  Korah's rebellion is mentioned as well in Jude.  And I think Paul had Numbers 13 and 14 in mind in Hebrews 6.

Still, if you want to use the New Testament to decide what you consider Canon, referencing events isn't the same as quoting it as Scripture.  The New Testament arguably references many events not recorded in any canonical book of Scripture.

However I definitely think any Prophecy the book of Revelation clearly references is meant to be viewed as a Canonical Prophecy, since Revelation exists to tie all of Prophecy together.  That includes material from Daniel, Isaiah, Ezekiel and more.

Now, "that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet" in Matthew 27:9 is not a contradiction, first off there is a connection to Jeremiah 32:6-9.  Second, chapters 9-14 of Zachariah unlike the earlier chapters do not begin with Zachariah identifying himself, it's possible he was recording additional prophecies of Jeremiah that he gave after his own Book was finished, and that weren't scribed by Baruch accounting for a different literary style.

If you choose to divide Daniel between it's Hebrew and Aramaic portions.  It's interesting that only Hebrew Daniel is directly quoted, but Aramaic Daniel is more so what Revelation draws on.

The author of the first link also calculates Psalms to be the most quoted book, and Isaiah second.  But most curious is in 3rd place is Deuteronomy as the most quoted of The Torah.  But since Deuteronomy mostly repeats and revisits stuff from earlier, much of that could be iffy.  However what Jesus calls the greatest commandment is definitely a quote of Deuteronomy 6.  And the Prophet like Unto Moses prophecy and the Song of Moses are two subjects unique to Deuteronomy that come up in the New Testament, the later in Revelation. 

I've always been of the opinion that Esther is just as important as Exodus 12 to understanding how the Passion week fulfilled the Old Testament, particularly my belief that the Resurrection/First Fruits of 30 AD was on the 17th of Nisan.  But I can hardly indisputably prove the New Testament authors intended that.

The apparent lack of New Testament verification for the Song of Solomon is rather disappointing to me, given one of the agendas I have on this blog.

Some people might argue certain books being kept in the same Scroll in the old Hebrew Canon means Jesus probably endorsed the entire scroll if he quoted any.  For the most part that is pretty arbitrary, considering we don't even know when the arrangement we're familiar with started, (Josephus seems to refer to a different number of scrolls, and said the Torah was 7 books not 5).  Lamentations was also written by Jeremiah, so it being in Jeremiah's scroll isn't a coincidence.  The Minor Prophets being in the same scroll is a pretty arbitrary thing to make a point out of however.

If you're a Jesus words only person, you potentially have to throw out even more.  The second link I've provided in this post says Jesus only quoted 24 books. 

Jesus makes references historically to David and Solomon and Elijah, and debate-ably to the Zechariah killed in the Temple in 2 Chronicles.  But nothing that fits the first link's standards of a direct quote of any of the dual books of Samuel, Kings or Chronicles (which were all 1 book originally).  In fact they are only quoted directly in the New Testament because of Paul, in his epistles and in what he says in Acts 13.  So all these people rejecting Paul because they love the Hebrew Bible so much, are unwittingly opening the door to reject much of the Hebrew Bible.  This is interesting because there are a lot of people out there who want to reinterpret David as a villain, some while still seeing themselves as consistent with New Testament Christianity.

Fortunately, Jesus quotes both so called First Isaiah and the so called Second Isaiah and attributes them to Isaiah.

Ezra and Nehemiah are interesting.  They shared the same scroll, and for good reason, Nehemiah is clearly a sequel to Ezra's narrative, so it's difficult to consider Nehemiah canon without considering Ezra Canon.  Both links agree the New Testament never quotes Ezra, but the first says Jesus quotes Nehemiah 9:15 in John 6:31.  However that same verse of John is also cited as quoting Psalm 78:24.  My reading of the three verses in question leads me to conclude Jesus was not exactly quoting either, but the source material could easily have been just the Psalm.

Jesus says in John 4 that the second Temple had some form of Divine presence at that time (that ended at Pentecost when The Church become God's Temple).  But the books themselves admit the Second Temple never had the full Shekinah Glory that the Desert Tabernacle and Solomon's Temple had.  So perhaps even if these book are canonical as an account of history, we should perhaps second guess the authority of decisions made by felible men in this period.

Which is important considering that a website I know of arguing against interracial marriage says "The Messiah upheld the rulings of Ezra and Nehemiah", which is not the case, even if the verse from John 6 did have Nehemiah in mind, it's just Jesus drawing on Nehemiah's wording to describe an event of the wilderness wandering.  It cannot count as an endorsement of Nehemiah or Ezra's opinions on how to interpret the Torah.  In The Torah God being fine with Moses marrying a Cushite woman proves he was fine with Hamites marrying Semites.

On my Prophecy blog I did a post on Nehemiah's quotation of Deuteronomy 30.  Where I showed the view of that held by Anti-Zionist Christians can't allow them to agree with Nehemiah's.  And I also expressed that I think the Second Temple was built both on the wrong location and had the wrong shape.

The problem with wanting to limit one's Canon to what Jesus or the New Testament quoted is that when Jesus quoted something as Scripture calling it Scripture he was referring to something the Jews at the time already considered canon. Second Timothy 3:16 also infers a Canon that was already agreed upon.

The thing is it's alleged the Hebrew Canon didn't become what we know it as now till the Council of Jamnia in the 90s AD.   However that conclusion is debatable.  The Mishna and Talmud refers to this council as some people wanting to question what was already considered canon.  With the Song of Solomon and Ecclesiastes being two that were called into question.  That context implies they were considered Canon in Jesus time, and so if Jesus was upholding the then upheld Canon, it can be inferred to include them.

Also the Kariates seem to have agreed to the same Hebrew Canon even thought they reject the Rabbis.  In fact it is primarily Karaites who preserved the Masoretic text that most today base their Hebrew Bible on, including the KJV.

However one could also argue that Jesus summarized the Hebrew Bible as just "The Law and The Prophets", and so see the lack of quoting the other Historical books as noteworthy. However Jesus clearly quoted the Psalms as Scripture, with Psalm 110 being the most quoted chapter of the Old Testament in the New Testament, and Jesus attributes it to David.   But Acts 2 calls David a Prophet.