That this can happen is popularly taught by some pastors.
I'm not saying it can't happen, issues like the Mark of The Beast are difficult to deal with. That issue is of course purely eschatological. If your even concerned about these kinds of issues that's solid evidence the Holy Spirit hasn't given up on you.
My ultimate point for this post is that no specific external Sin or amount of Sin should be used as outward evidence someone has reached that point. Paul called himself the Chief of Sinners (1 Timothy 1:15) and indeed he persecuted the Faith, I really don't think any Sin would be more difficult for God to forgive then being a persecutor of his children. But we have Proof in Paul you can be redeemed even from that.
People like to cite in Hosea when God says "I will love them no more" This ignores the context of the entirety of Hosea, where he is talking about the people of Israel and clearly saying they will ultimately be forgiven and brought back to him. This is not about an individual person(s). Like how Calvinists misuse the references to Esau and Jacob in Malachi and Romans, those are about the nations, not the individuals.
Romans 1 (which I'll talk more on latter) is cited as a reference to God giving people over unto Sin. And they think that means they can't be saved anymore. And will compare it to God hardening Pharaoh's Heart.
Not only is being delivered unto Sin by God not proof you can't be Saved, it isn't even proof your not already Saved. Saul was Saved well before God sent an Evil Spirit to afflict him for his Sin. And in 1 Timothy 1:20 Paul speaks of Hymenaeus and Alexander being delivered unto Satan. Their clearly spoken of as being fellow believers, but ones with problems. And he said that was done so they''d learn a lesson.
Using Romans 1 that way ignores the context of Romans 2 and 3 which follow. Where Paul tells the believers he's talking to that they are no better, they're guilty of every single Sin he described the Pagan Romans engaging in in Chapter 1, weather they realize it or not.
One interpretation of Hebrews 6 taken by some fellow believers in Eternal Security is that it's not describing people who were ever saved, but people who understood The Gospel and outright rejected it.
They are explicitly described as Falling Away. And they tasted the Gifts of The Spirit, that is not comparable to the way the Holy Spirit sometimes moves unsaved people. The Gifts of The Spirit are for those He truly indwells in only.
I recommend Chuck Missler's explanation of Hebrews 6. First of all the fact that is clear in the Greek Grammar (and not in conflict the KJV reading) is that it's God who won't Repent. God often says rhetorically he'll do something and then repents of it. But when he swears and Oath he won't Repent.
Hebrews 6 needs to be understood in light of Numbers 13-14. The people rejected The Land because of the spies report. The Angered God, and he said (rhetorically at least, that he's destroy them for that that). But Moses prayed for them and said to God that the Egyptians would hear it and say "Because the LORD was not able to bring this people into the land which he sware
unto them, therefore he hath slain them in the wilderness."
So in 14:20 God says he shall forgive and pardon them. But they still had repercussions for That Sin he would not turn back from.
Nothing in Hebrews 6 or 10 says the people being spoken of go to Hell.
The Blasphemy against The Holy Spirit is a difficult issue. It is first of all spoken of in a way that implies it's the absolute only unforgivable Sin. But those who want to accuse other Sins of being evidence of inability to be Saved just say those are Sins you can't commit till after who's done the unpardonable Sin.
If we define what The Blasphemy against The Holy Spirit is based on the context of The Story, it's accusing something done by The Holy Ghost of being done by Demons. Thing is, sadly, Independent Baptists who's salvation I don't question risk doing this attacking Pentecostals and Charismatics all the time. Of course the specific context is casting out Demons. Matthew 7 proves unsaved people can cast out Demons, but they don't do it by Demons, they still clearly did it in Jesus name. Their damned because they placed their faith in those Works not in Him.
I think some of what we assume about what Jesus meant here may be wrong. In the Mark account he says of those who had done this "But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost hath never forgiveness, but
is in danger of eternal damnation".
Danger does not mean guaranteed. So if your KJV only, you have to admit maybe they're not as Un-Saveable as we assume.
"But, they receive no forgiveness?". Aren't we Christians supposed to ask forgiveness when we Sin? Even though we're already Saved and can't lose that Salvation? There might be a difference in terms of forgiveness at the Bema Judgment and forgiveness at the White Throne Judgment.
Since many consider Matthew 12 as when the leadership of Israel formally rejects Jesus as Messiah. This may also be meant to be compared to Numbers 13-14. Besides, it is implied in Acts latter that most of the Phrasiees did become believers.
Now I want to go back to Romans 1. I've expressed elsewhere why I don't think verses 26-27 meant what most think it means. But that's immaterial to the discussion here.
One thing both I and people who hold the traditional view on Homosexuality agree on is that the "abusers of themselves with mankind" in 1 Corinthians 6:9-10 is referring to the same thing Romans 1:26-27 refers to. Verse 11 makes clear there were Saved people in the Corinthian congregation saved out of every single one of those Sins listed. Then verse 12 says "All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient: all things are
lawful for me, but I will not be brought under the power of any." Showing how we're not bound by The Law (New or Old Testament Law), but there are still good reasons to follow it.
Certain Pastors will back up viewing Homosexuals as beyond Salvation by saying "It's not part of the Sin Nature" and talking about how they (and presumably most people) are never even tempted to do that.
I have never been tempted to Drink Alcohol, or Smoke Cigarettes, or do any Drugs. And plenty of other Sins. Each individual is different, just because you can't relate to something doesn't mean it's inherently abnormal.
The word for "Nature" in Romans 1:26-27 is the same in both the Greek and Hebrew as when Paul refers to men having long hair in 1 Corinthians 11:14. Does Paul intend to say that's something that is biologically unnatural? No clearly not. Also in the Greek the word for "shame" in the Corinthians verse is the same a "vile" in Romans. This is the most similar passage to Romans in terms of how Paul uses those two key words.
Another verse they will bring up is Corinthians 10:13 "There hath no temptation taken you but such as is common to man: but God is
faithful, who will not suffer you to be tempted above that ye are able; but will
with the temptation also make a way to escape, that ye may be able to bear it." Which they take to mean believers can't be tempted by anything uncommon.
Paul's intent here was not to create a way to know what temptation we can't face, but to assure all his readers every temptation they face is common, they are not alone. In fact I see no reason to use this verse as evidence that "uncommon sins" exist at all.
The problem with people using this verse this way is that they think common equals majority. When I was collecting Pokemon cards as a kid the Ratata card was labeled common, that did not mean 51% of all cards were Ratata. I think the percentage of cards that were Ratata was in fact smaller then the percentage of the human race that has felt some form of sexual desire for the same sex.
This same epistle refers to others thing that would be "Uncommon" by the same standard if Homosexuality was uncommon as being sins people within the Body were dealing with.
All of my posts on this Blog are meant to be Conversation Starters. I never want to be the final word on any topic. I'm trying to put ideas out there that hopefully others more knowledgeable and skilled then me can expand on.
Wednesday, October 22, 2014
Monday, October 20, 2014
Judge not, that ye be not judged
Matthew 7:1
This is a popular verse to quote. But it's also popular for "Conservative" Christians to insist that "Liberal" Christians are taking this verse out of context when they quote it with the intent of saying Judgmentalness is inherently Un-Christian.
They say the point Jesus goes on to make is that you need to make sure your not guilty yourself of the Sin your Judging someone for before you judge them.
No, the point of everything Jesus goes on to say is like all the verses where he talks about the importance of not sinning with the intent of showing we can't be saved by our own Righteousness. Read Romans 1-3.
In John 8, when Jesus said "Let he among you who is without Sin cast the first stone". There is no qualifier of not guilty of the same sin. Paul said we are all Sinners.
"But, when your Saved you won't be or at least shouldn't be sinning like you did before". Again Romans 1-3 Paul is specifically telling those believers they're in error for judging the non believers.
We are supposed to be informing the World that we're all condemned because we're all imperfect. But Jesus died to take the penalty of Sin for us.
Judgment is for Jesus alone.
This is a popular verse to quote. But it's also popular for "Conservative" Christians to insist that "Liberal" Christians are taking this verse out of context when they quote it with the intent of saying Judgmentalness is inherently Un-Christian.
They say the point Jesus goes on to make is that you need to make sure your not guilty yourself of the Sin your Judging someone for before you judge them.
No, the point of everything Jesus goes on to say is like all the verses where he talks about the importance of not sinning with the intent of showing we can't be saved by our own Righteousness. Read Romans 1-3.
In John 8, when Jesus said "Let he among you who is without Sin cast the first stone". There is no qualifier of not guilty of the same sin. Paul said we are all Sinners.
"But, when your Saved you won't be or at least shouldn't be sinning like you did before". Again Romans 1-3 Paul is specifically telling those believers they're in error for judging the non believers.
We are supposed to be informing the World that we're all condemned because we're all imperfect. But Jesus died to take the penalty of Sin for us.
Judgment is for Jesus alone.
Friday, October 17, 2014
Judas being Lost
So I was reading one website attacking Eternal Security suggesting that the way Eternal Security believers use part of John 17:12 "I have kept, and none of them is lost" as being undermined by the following statement in regard to Judas.
First of all, they horribly misrepresent the passage by saying "Jesus admits to losing Judas". This passage is not an admission of any failure. "I kept them in thy name: those that thou gavest me I have kept, and none of them is lost, but the son of perdition; that the scripture might be fulfilled." This is presented as the absolute only exception, the exception that proves the rule. We this absolute only one exception principle elsewhere in Scripture, the Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is the only Sin that won't be forgiven.
The reason Judas is allowed to be Lost is to fulfill Bible Prophecy. Psalm 19 and Zachariah 11, the Idol Sheppard that Leaves the Flock. There are no Bible Prophecies about Salvation being lost. Jesus said to the damned in Matthew 7 (even specifically proffering Christians who are damned) he NEVER knew them. There is no such state of a damned former believer.
Scholars may debate all day if Judas was really Saved and lost it, or just rhetorically being spoken of as if he was one of them (I prefer the latter view). But either way the point is he's one of a Kind. Son of Perdition is a Unique title used only once elsewhere in Scripture, where I believe it's The False Prophet. And still the same person as Judas.
First of all, they horribly misrepresent the passage by saying "Jesus admits to losing Judas". This passage is not an admission of any failure. "I kept them in thy name: those that thou gavest me I have kept, and none of them is lost, but the son of perdition; that the scripture might be fulfilled." This is presented as the absolute only exception, the exception that proves the rule. We this absolute only one exception principle elsewhere in Scripture, the Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit is the only Sin that won't be forgiven.
The reason Judas is allowed to be Lost is to fulfill Bible Prophecy. Psalm 19 and Zachariah 11, the Idol Sheppard that Leaves the Flock. There are no Bible Prophecies about Salvation being lost. Jesus said to the damned in Matthew 7 (even specifically proffering Christians who are damned) he NEVER knew them. There is no such state of a damned former believer.
Scholars may debate all day if Judas was really Saved and lost it, or just rhetorically being spoken of as if he was one of them (I prefer the latter view). But either way the point is he's one of a Kind. Son of Perdition is a Unique title used only once elsewhere in Scripture, where I believe it's The False Prophet. And still the same person as Judas.
Thursday, October 16, 2014
What is Repentance
I had an earlier post on Repentance and Salvation. I stand by my points there, but what's more important is what Repentance means.
The Greek word translated Repent means a change of mind. A Change how how you think. Mark 1:15 says "repent ye, and believe the gospel". It's all about Belief.
The people who overemphasis Repentance, who puts memes on Facebook saying "If your Gospel doesn't include Repentance your teaching a False Gospel", think Repent means to Turn from Sin. It doesn't mean that. Judas Repented of what he had done, and then went and immediately committed Suicide.
One more thing. John's Baptism is defined as the Baptism of Repentance. Matthew 3:11, Mark 1:4, Luke 3:3, Acts 13:24 and19:4. Some view that as part of argument Johns' Baptism was a different Baptism then what the Apostles Baptized. I don't have an opinion on that yet, but either way the point here is. Jesus was Baptized by John? Why? He was Without Sin?
The reason is Jesus did everything necessary for Salvation for us. Including Repentance.
The Greek word translated Repent means a change of mind. A Change how how you think. Mark 1:15 says "repent ye, and believe the gospel". It's all about Belief.
The people who overemphasis Repentance, who puts memes on Facebook saying "If your Gospel doesn't include Repentance your teaching a False Gospel", think Repent means to Turn from Sin. It doesn't mean that. Judas Repented of what he had done, and then went and immediately committed Suicide.
One more thing. John's Baptism is defined as the Baptism of Repentance. Matthew 3:11, Mark 1:4, Luke 3:3, Acts 13:24 and19:4. Some view that as part of argument Johns' Baptism was a different Baptism then what the Apostles Baptized. I don't have an opinion on that yet, but either way the point here is. Jesus was Baptized by John? Why? He was Without Sin?
The reason is Jesus did everything necessary for Salvation for us. Including Repentance.
Wednesday, October 15, 2014
Female Partnerships in The New Testament
Romans 16:12 says "Salute Tryphena and Tryphosa, who labour in the Lord." Both of those are universally in all Greek and English texts female names. Both the use of the word "labour" and the context and function of Romans 16 confirm that Tryphaena and Tryphosa should be seen as missionaries.
Paul's usage of only one verb for the two means they're a missionary couple. The other four missionary couples mentioned are all one male and one female. Priscilla and Aquila, Andronicus and Junia, Philologus and Julia are the first three, the nature of how they're related isn't specified. But we know from elsewhere in the New Testament like Acts that Priscilla and Aquilla are husband and wife. The Fourth is Nereus and his sister. With the Male-Female pairs it is inferred that if how their related isn't mentioned they are probably husband and wife.
Philippians 4 mentions Euodia and Syntyche.
When he describes the ministry of Euodia and Syntyche, Paul uses a couple of the same terms he had previously applied to Timothy and Epaphroditus. Paul writes that Euodia and Syntyche had contended together with him “in the Gospel”. Earlier in the same letter, Paul had also described Timothy as someone who had served with him “in the Gospel” (Phil. 2:22). Paul goes on torefer to Euodia and Syntyche as his “fellow-workers“. Earlier, Paul had also referred to Epaphroditus as his “fellow-worker” (Phil. 2:25).
So, according to Paul, the ministries of the women Euodia and Syntyche
were comparable to the ministries of the men Timothy and Epaphroditus.
Early church bishop and theologian, John Chrysostom (c349-407), believed that Euodia and Syntyche were leaders in the Philippian church. Moreover, he compared them to Phoebe, a woman minister (diakonos) in Cenchrea (Rom. 16:1-2). In his 13th Homily on Philippians he wrote:
I think this information should open people's eyes somewhat. This pattern of Female Partnerships can possibly be expanded into Extra-Biblical examples, where possible evidence of Homo-Romantic affection exists but is frequently ignored. The acts of Paul and Thecla has another Tryphena sponsor Thecla. Perpetua and Felicity believed to have been Martyrs in 203 AD Artemilla and Eubula in the Apocryphal acts of Paul. Maximilla and Iphidamia in the Acts of Andrew. Of course there are also themes in these apocryphal stories that reflect some of the problematic Misogynist attitudes of the developing Church as well. Especially in the Acts of Thomas which features Mygdonia, Marcia and Tetria.
Paul's usage of only one verb for the two means they're a missionary couple. The other four missionary couples mentioned are all one male and one female. Priscilla and Aquila, Andronicus and Junia, Philologus and Julia are the first three, the nature of how they're related isn't specified. But we know from elsewhere in the New Testament like Acts that Priscilla and Aquilla are husband and wife. The Fourth is Nereus and his sister. With the Male-Female pairs it is inferred that if how their related isn't mentioned they are probably husband and wife.
Philippians 4 mentions Euodia and Syntyche.
When he describes the ministry of Euodia and Syntyche, Paul uses a couple of the same terms he had previously applied to Timothy and Epaphroditus. Paul writes that Euodia and Syntyche had contended together with him “in the Gospel”. Earlier in the same letter, Paul had also described Timothy as someone who had served with him “in the Gospel” (Phil. 2:22). Paul goes on to
Early church bishop and theologian, John Chrysostom (c349-407), believed that Euodia and Syntyche were leaders in the Philippian church. Moreover, he compared them to Phoebe, a woman minister (diakonos) in Cenchrea (Rom. 16:1-2). In his 13th Homily on Philippians he wrote:
These women [Euodia and Syntyche] seem to me to be the chief of the Church which was there, and [Paul] commends them to some notable man whom he calls his yokefellow; [Paul] commends them to him, as to a fellow-worker, and fellow-soldier, and brother, and companion, as he does in the Epistle to the Romans, when he says, I commend to you Phoebe our sister, who is aIt is commonly assumed the conflict Paul alludes to is between the two women. However comparing to other Paulian passages I feel the disagreement is between Paul himself and the two women. Like First Corinthians 1:10. Earlier in Philippians 1:14-17 Paul refers to others preaching the Gospel in competition to himself. In verse 18 we see that Paul rejoices at this. Another perspective has been offered also.minister of the church at Cenchrea (Romans 16:1). (Homilies on Philippians, 13)
Phillipi was a region where Women were more independent then most parts of Greece at this time. Acts 16:12-17 even calls attention to this.In Philippians 4:2, Paul urged Euodia and he urged Syntyche to, literally, “think the same thing”. That Paul addressed Euodia and Syntyche personally and individually, reinforces the idea that these women had considerable influence in the Philippian church and probably were leaders.Were Euodia and Syntyche quarrelling? This is the assumption most people have, and many Bible versions convey this assumption in their translations. Paul, however, does not say, or intimate, that Euodia and Syntyche were quarrelling. Paul simply urged each of them (literally) “to think the same thing in the Lord”. “Think” (phroneō) is a key word in the letter to the Philippians. In the preceding verses in Philippians, Paul had been encouraging mature people to have the same thinking as himself – that of reaching out for the goal spiritual perfection (Phil. 3:14-15). It could well be that Paul is carrying on this thought and, using almost identical language (in the Greek), is saying, “I encourage Euodia and I encourage Syntyche to have the same thinking in the Lord ” that of aspiring to spiritual maturity and perfection (Phil. 4:2).Chrysostom did not see any sign of a quarrel in Paul’s plea to Euodia and Syntyche; he saw only praise from Paul and wrote: “Do you see how great a testimony he [Paul] bears to their virtue?” (Homilies on Philippians, 13)
I think this information should open people's eyes somewhat. This pattern of Female Partnerships can possibly be expanded into Extra-Biblical examples, where possible evidence of Homo-Romantic affection exists but is frequently ignored. The acts of Paul and Thecla has another Tryphena sponsor Thecla. Perpetua and Felicity believed to have been Martyrs in 203 AD Artemilla and Eubula in the Apocryphal acts of Paul. Maximilla and Iphidamia in the Acts of Andrew. Of course there are also themes in these apocryphal stories that reflect some of the problematic Misogynist attitudes of the developing Church as well. Especially in the Acts of Thomas which features Mygdonia, Marcia and Tetria.
Tuesday, October 14, 2014
Questioning The Salvation of Fellow Believers
Seems to be a favorite pastime among Christians today.
Even a lot of believers who say they believe in Eternal Security, really simply mean by that the Fifth Point of Calvinism, or some variation there of. That certain Sins, or Apostasy, or Bad Doctrine can be used as proof of a lack of true Salvation in a professing Christian.
Like people who believe Salvation can be Lost or in Works Salvation they will miss use verses there for the purposes of showing how impossible it is to earn Salvation.
But they will add to those verses, verses that are about Works as evidence of Faith. The Evidence of Faith in question isn't for other Believers, but about Witnessing. The great Commission actually says in the Greek to "Be A Witness". We should be credible representatives of God's Kingdom. That is why Jesus told the Apostles that The World will Know them by their Love for one another. And why Nathan told David he gave Occasion to the Enemies of The LORD to Blaspheme after he sinned with Bathsheba and killed Uria.
Faith without Works is Dead. But you can't have Dead Faith if you never had Faith.
1 Corinthians 3:15 says "If any man's work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire."
Saul we know was Saved. His Salvation was depicted before he became King. Yet he backslid horribly and became a Villain of David's Story. But when his Death was foretold Samuel said he and his Sons would be with him. I know in the Old Testament, before The Cross all the Saved went to Sheol. But in Luke 16 we're informed it has two distinct compartments for the Saved and Unsaved. What Samuel said there isn't with him as in their both in the same place the same way someone in Racine or Milwaukee are both in Wisconsin. It means they will be together.
Solomon also didn't Persevere to the end. And Lot and Samson were both Worldly. The latter each have New Testament verses confirming their Salvation.
Hebrew 6, and latter parts of Hebrew elaborating on the same Subject are controversial. I agree with Chris White that the Sin in mind here is Apostasy (not bad doctrine, but renouncing your faith). But he's wrong in taking the view that Apostasy is the one exception to Eternal Security.
I highly Recommend what Chuck Missler says on Hebrews 6, (he falls into the same traps Calvinists do on some other verses, but on Hebrew 6 he nails it). He points out issues with the Greek Grammar that aren't easily carried over into English. But mostly bases his point on going back to the Old Testament passage it draws on, Numbers 13-14, the Spies who rejected The Land. God was very angry with them, but Moses Prayed for them and they were Forgiven, BUT they were not allowed to see The Land and that's why they wondered for 40 years. Likewise when a Saved person commits Apostasy Jesus Prays for him just as he Prayed for Peter.
The Prodigal Son squandered his Inheritance but did not lose his Sonship. When Jesus in Matthew refers to the "Outer Darkness" that is not Hell. That refers to being Outside New Jerusalem, where The Light of God will be. Some people refuse to admit that not all the Saved are New Jerusalem. But Revelation 21:24-27 makes clear there are entire nations outside. Many are simply because they weren't Saved during the Church Age, but there will also be Church Age believers who lose their Citizenship of The Holy City, but not their Salvation.
A certain pastor I don't want to name, who teaches Eternal Security, and preaches against all Five points of Calvinism, still loves to question people's Salvation based on Doctrine.
He says based on "My sheep hear my voice and follow me" that whatever problems they have, a truly Saved person will respond to God's Word. This verse is about Salvation, and another one Calvinists might miss use to support their view of Predestination, but what their wrong on is the cause and effect.
This same Pastor agrees with me on using Saul to Prove Eternal Security, and also Solomon. But both of them heard God's Word from anointed Prophets and Priests trying to turn them from their backslidden paths yet they did not do so.
The KJV Biblical Word most Calvinists I've seen view as what they mean by "Persevere" is Overcome. Mainly how it's used in 1 John and Revelation 2-3. Overcome is used in many senses of many things in The Bible, plenty no Clavinsits thinks is about Salvation.
1 John 5:4-5 says
Some of the usages in Revelation 2-3 and 21:7 may or may not be using it specially of those who who don't lose their Inheritance. I believe all Seven Churches, even the two worst ones, were congregations of Saved individuals, or else Jesus wouldn't have written to them at all.
You're saved if you Overcome, but not every saved person will Overcome to the end.
Romans 10 says "All who call upon the name of The Lord shall be Saved" no qualifying statements. 1 John 4:2 says " Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God". And verse 15 says "Whosoever shall confess that Jesus is the Son of God, God dwelleth in him, and he in God."
I'm not saying there are no professing Christians who aren't saved. But those that are are people who were born in the faith, or who converted for the wrong reasons. But everyone who understands they need a Savior and accept Jesus is Saved.
"But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness." - Romans 4:5
"Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the
deeds of the law." - Romans 3:28
"For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast." - Ephesians 2:8,9
Even a lot of believers who say they believe in Eternal Security, really simply mean by that the Fifth Point of Calvinism, or some variation there of. That certain Sins, or Apostasy, or Bad Doctrine can be used as proof of a lack of true Salvation in a professing Christian.
Like people who believe Salvation can be Lost or in Works Salvation they will miss use verses there for the purposes of showing how impossible it is to earn Salvation.
But they will add to those verses, verses that are about Works as evidence of Faith. The Evidence of Faith in question isn't for other Believers, but about Witnessing. The great Commission actually says in the Greek to "Be A Witness". We should be credible representatives of God's Kingdom. That is why Jesus told the Apostles that The World will Know them by their Love for one another. And why Nathan told David he gave Occasion to the Enemies of The LORD to Blaspheme after he sinned with Bathsheba and killed Uria.
Faith without Works is Dead. But you can't have Dead Faith if you never had Faith.
1 Corinthians 3:15 says "If any man's work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire."
Saul we know was Saved. His Salvation was depicted before he became King. Yet he backslid horribly and became a Villain of David's Story. But when his Death was foretold Samuel said he and his Sons would be with him. I know in the Old Testament, before The Cross all the Saved went to Sheol. But in Luke 16 we're informed it has two distinct compartments for the Saved and Unsaved. What Samuel said there isn't with him as in their both in the same place the same way someone in Racine or Milwaukee are both in Wisconsin. It means they will be together.
Solomon also didn't Persevere to the end. And Lot and Samson were both Worldly. The latter each have New Testament verses confirming their Salvation.
Hebrew 6, and latter parts of Hebrew elaborating on the same Subject are controversial. I agree with Chris White that the Sin in mind here is Apostasy (not bad doctrine, but renouncing your faith). But he's wrong in taking the view that Apostasy is the one exception to Eternal Security.
I highly Recommend what Chuck Missler says on Hebrews 6, (he falls into the same traps Calvinists do on some other verses, but on Hebrew 6 he nails it). He points out issues with the Greek Grammar that aren't easily carried over into English. But mostly bases his point on going back to the Old Testament passage it draws on, Numbers 13-14, the Spies who rejected The Land. God was very angry with them, but Moses Prayed for them and they were Forgiven, BUT they were not allowed to see The Land and that's why they wondered for 40 years. Likewise when a Saved person commits Apostasy Jesus Prays for him just as he Prayed for Peter.
The Prodigal Son squandered his Inheritance but did not lose his Sonship. When Jesus in Matthew refers to the "Outer Darkness" that is not Hell. That refers to being Outside New Jerusalem, where The Light of God will be. Some people refuse to admit that not all the Saved are New Jerusalem. But Revelation 21:24-27 makes clear there are entire nations outside. Many are simply because they weren't Saved during the Church Age, but there will also be Church Age believers who lose their Citizenship of The Holy City, but not their Salvation.
A certain pastor I don't want to name, who teaches Eternal Security, and preaches against all Five points of Calvinism, still loves to question people's Salvation based on Doctrine.
He says based on "My sheep hear my voice and follow me" that whatever problems they have, a truly Saved person will respond to God's Word. This verse is about Salvation, and another one Calvinists might miss use to support their view of Predestination, but what their wrong on is the cause and effect.
This same Pastor agrees with me on using Saul to Prove Eternal Security, and also Solomon. But both of them heard God's Word from anointed Prophets and Priests trying to turn them from their backslidden paths yet they did not do so.
The KJV Biblical Word most Calvinists I've seen view as what they mean by "Persevere" is Overcome. Mainly how it's used in 1 John and Revelation 2-3. Overcome is used in many senses of many things in The Bible, plenty no Clavinsits thinks is about Salvation.
1 John 5:4-5 says
"For whatsoever is born of God overcometh the world: and this is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith. Who is he that overcometh the world, but he that believeth that Jesus is the Son of God?"What John means here is clearly all the Saved. And doesn't matter if you Persevered to the end or not, simply Believing means you overcome the world.
Some of the usages in Revelation 2-3 and 21:7 may or may not be using it specially of those who who don't lose their Inheritance. I believe all Seven Churches, even the two worst ones, were congregations of Saved individuals, or else Jesus wouldn't have written to them at all.
You're saved if you Overcome, but not every saved person will Overcome to the end.
Romans 10 says "All who call upon the name of The Lord shall be Saved" no qualifying statements. 1 John 4:2 says " Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God". And verse 15 says "Whosoever shall confess that Jesus is the Son of God, God dwelleth in him, and he in God."
I'm not saying there are no professing Christians who aren't saved. But those that are are people who were born in the faith, or who converted for the wrong reasons. But everyone who understands they need a Savior and accept Jesus is Saved.
"But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness." - Romans 4:5
"Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the
"For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast." - Ephesians 2:8,9
Friday, October 10, 2014
Homosexuality and Church History
Prudish attitudes have always existed, and plenty of quotes among the Church Father show the seeds of Homophobia existed among them. The Church Fathers were of course also Anti-Semitic which is why they had to be Post-Trib.
Still, some quotes used by "Conservatives" to back up their view that Homosexuality has always been consistently condemned are misused just as The Bible verses are.
The Didache is considered the oldest Christian writing not part of the Canon. The passage from it cited as condemning Homosexuality is.
The quote from Polycarp's epistle to the Corinthians that is cited against homosexuality from section 5 uses the same two words as 1 Corinthians 6. Yet one translation chooses to render them "nor the passive homosexual partner, nor the dominant homosexual partner", which I explained elsewhere there are far better ways to express that.
The Epistle of Barnabas is a popular piece of Apocrypha. Some people will cite it as if it actually was written by Barnabas the friend of Paul (Conservopedia wrongly dates it 74 AD). But that is impossible, it was clearly written during The Bar Kochba Revolt, when The Jews were planning to rebuild The Temple. This is why it's also the first Christian writing to advocate for a form of replacement theology.
On the Homosexuality subject it is quoted as saying "You shall not commit prostitution; you shall not commit adultery; you shall not be a corrupter of youth". Again, it's a reference to specifically Pederasty that people want to cite as if it and Homosexuality were inseparable. Which is what lots of modern Christian Homophobes argue. But that is not how Doctrine should be built (if we were building doctrine on this extra-Biblical text at all, which we shouldn't).
There certainly were attitudes among the Church Father against any same sex relations. But remember, these are the same people out of whom came The Catholic Church.
In terms of the references that specifically bring up Lesbians. I feel it can be well demonstrated that the Anit-Lesbain attitudes some Church Fathers had was an example of then endorsing the prevailing attitudes of the Pagan Greco-Romon world, rather then rebelling against it. A few Non-Christian scholars of Lesbian history have spoken on this subject, though accepting the wrong view that Lesbianism is addressed in Romans 1. Like Bernadette Brooten.
Still, some quotes used by "Conservatives" to back up their view that Homosexuality has always been consistently condemned are misused just as The Bible verses are.
The Didache is considered the oldest Christian writing not part of the Canon. The passage from it cited as condemning Homosexuality is.
"You shall not commit murder, you shall not commit adultery, you shall not commit pederasty, you shall not commit prostitution, you shall not steal, you shall not practice magic, you shall not practice witchcraft, you shall not murder a child by abortion nor kill one that has been born." - Didache 2:2The basis here is the use of "pederasty". That term is NOT for any and all Homosexual acts however, it refers specifically to an older Man with a much younger Boy. A Boy who'd be a Minor by modern legal standards and also probably ancient ones too.
The quote from Polycarp's epistle to the Corinthians that is cited against homosexuality from section 5 uses the same two words as 1 Corinthians 6. Yet one translation chooses to render them "nor the passive homosexual partner, nor the dominant homosexual partner", which I explained elsewhere there are far better ways to express that.
The Epistle of Barnabas is a popular piece of Apocrypha. Some people will cite it as if it actually was written by Barnabas the friend of Paul (Conservopedia wrongly dates it 74 AD). But that is impossible, it was clearly written during The Bar Kochba Revolt, when The Jews were planning to rebuild The Temple. This is why it's also the first Christian writing to advocate for a form of replacement theology.
On the Homosexuality subject it is quoted as saying "You shall not commit prostitution; you shall not commit adultery; you shall not be a corrupter of youth". Again, it's a reference to specifically Pederasty that people want to cite as if it and Homosexuality were inseparable. Which is what lots of modern Christian Homophobes argue. But that is not how Doctrine should be built (if we were building doctrine on this extra-Biblical text at all, which we shouldn't).
...to expose newly-born children is the part of wicked men; and this we have been taught lest we should do anyone harm and lest we should sin against God, first, because we see that almost all so exposed (not only the girls, but also the males) are brought up to prostitution. And for this pollution a multitude of females and hermaphrodites, and those who commit unmentionable iniquities, are found in every nation...And there are some who prostitute even their own children and wives, and some are openly mutilated for the purpose of sodomy; and they refer these mysteries to the mother of the gods. - Justin Martyr, First Apology 27 (A.D. 151).This is clearly about Pagan ritual prostitution.
All honor to that king of the Scythians, whoever Anacharsis was, who shot with an arrow one of his subjects who imitated among the Scythians the mystery of the mother of the gods . . . condemning him as having become effeminate among the Greeks, and a teacher of the disease of effeminacy to the rest of the Scythians. Clement of Alexandria, Exhortation to the Greeks 2 (A.D. 190).Again, more of what I said above, and of what I said about Malakos in my main Homosexuality dissertation.
For your gods did not even abstain from boys, one having loved Hylas, another Hyacinthus, another Pelops, another Chrysippus, another Ganymede. - Clement of Alexandria, Exhortation to the Greeks 2 (A.D. 190).Again, he said "boys" not "men".
There certainly were attitudes among the Church Father against any same sex relations. But remember, these are the same people out of whom came The Catholic Church.
In terms of the references that specifically bring up Lesbians. I feel it can be well demonstrated that the Anit-Lesbain attitudes some Church Fathers had was an example of then endorsing the prevailing attitudes of the Pagan Greco-Romon world, rather then rebelling against it. A few Non-Christian scholars of Lesbian history have spoken on this subject, though accepting the wrong view that Lesbianism is addressed in Romans 1. Like Bernadette Brooten.
Drawing upon a broad range of sources from the Roman world, I illustrate in my forthcoming book that early Christian views of female homoeroticism closely resembled those of their non-Christian contemporaries. Some prior researchers have tended to take an apologetic pro-Christian stance and to see early Christian sexual values as of a higher moral level than those of their environment. Other researchers have viewed early Christians as proto-Puritanical and repressive in contrast to the more sex-positive pagans around them. My research is more in line with those researchers who see a continuity between non-Christian and Christian understandings of the body. A focus on female homoeroticism makes this continuity clearer than would a focus on male homoeroticism, since nearly all extant sources on sexual relations between women condemn such relations, whereas some Roman-period, non-Christian sources express tolerance toward male-male sexual relations, which masks the similarity between Christian and non-Christian understandings of masculinity. Because the reasons for condemning female homoeroticism run deeper than the reasons for promoting marriage or celibacy (on which there was much debate in the Roman world), there is a cultural continuity of views of female homoeroticism.
Although ancient Christian writers resembled their non-Christian contemporaries in their views on erotic love between women, both groups differed from our own culture in their overall understanding of erotic orientation. Whereas we often dualistically define sexual orientation as either homosexual or heterosexual, they saw a plethora of orientations. (When we in the late 20th century think about it, we also recognize bisexuals and transsexuals, leading us to speak of a spectrum, rather than a bifurcation.) Their matrix of erotic orientations included whether a person took an active or a passive sexual role, as well as the gender, age, nationality, and the economic, legal (slave or free), and social status of the partner. For example, for the second-century astrologer Ptolemy, the configuration of the stars at one's birth determines a person's lifelong erotic orientation. A man born under one configuration is oriented toward females alone; under a second configuration, he desires to play a passive role toward males (i.e., to be penetrated); under a third, he desires to penetrate children; and under a fourth, he will desire males of any age. But the list does not end there. Other configurations give rise to men who desire low-status women, slave-women, or foreigners. In this schema, female homoeroticism constitutes one erotic orientation out of many, rather than a subcategory of two orientations (heterosexual and homosexual). Ptolemy and other authors reveal a gender bias in that they present far more differentiated pictures of the male erotic life than of the female one, even attributing more orientations to men than to women. By keeping in mind the larger picture of ancient classification systems for erotic orientation, the reader will better understand the specific discussions of female homoeroticism that I analyze in my book.Still, I have my suspicions that Lesbians did exist in The Early Church. It's that the patriarchs are the one's who've provided our written sources.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)