Friday, April 13, 2018

Free Will vs Predestination

Much of where I differ from other modern Evangelical Universalists may come down to how for most Origen is their favorite of the Early Church Fathers while I prefer the Church Fathers who were Universalists yet critical of Origen.  Because I'm concerned about the ways Origen anticipated things like Arianism via his Platonic ideas.

However my past uncomfortably with their tendency to reject Free Will isn't one of them.  Origen strongly taught Free Will and condemned those Gnostics who rejected it.  And so did Methodius of Olympus who was critical of Origen but possibly a fellow Universalist.  I do not however agree with Origen's desire to explain what Malachi says about Jacob and Esau via a Prexistence of Souls doctrine. 

I made a post on this blog already providing quotes about Free Will before Pelagius.  Pelagius's teaching may have included something I'd find heretical, I don't know, we know him only via what his critics said.  But the point is he didn't invent Free Will.

My perspective on the issue of Free Will and Predesintation has been, not changed so much as clarified since watching this video explaining what Calvin originally taught.

Calvin mentioned Universalism but without taking it seriously.  Because to him that was an absurdity. So he concluded that God must choose not to Save people in order to maintain God's Sovereignty.  Even though more then one passage in Scripture says it's not God's Will for any to Perish.  Matthew 18:14, 2 Peter 3:9 and 1 Timothy 2:3-4.

Non Calvanist opponents of Unviersalism would respond that the context is explaining why the Parusia is being delayed and clearly implies those who aren't saved before the Parusia are screwed.  The validity of that argument depends on other passages.  Calvinists however need to convince themselves that those verses are only talking about the Elect even though the context clearly doesn't support that.

As far as the claim that Romans 1 talks about "Reprobates".  Much of Romans 1 is rhetorically laying the views of those Paul is about to scold.  The rest of the Epistle goes on to refute the notion that God gives up on Sinners.

I have come to realize that instead of putting Universalism into the context of the position I already had on the Free Will/Predestination conflict, I should rather view Universalism as the solution to that conflict.  The Bible clearly teaches both Free Will and Predestination, and it is only an assumption that some will not be saved that sees a conflict there.

Jesus says in John 12:32 that He will draw all men unto him, the Greek terminology clearly implies the one being drawn isn't in control. 

We don't have Free Will in terms of Salvation, God won't allow us to destroy ourselves, nor destroy us for rejecting Him.  But we do have Free Will in terms of being a Believer in this Life, being a Citizen of the Kingdom, entering a Relationship with Him.  God makes the first move as Luther would say, because he's made that first move towards everyone, it's now on us to accept it.

1 John 2:2 destroys limited Atonement "And he is the propitiation for our sins: and not for ours only, but also for the sins of the whole world.".  As does 1 Timothy 2:6 "Who gave himself a ransom for all, to be testified in due time.".

1 Timothy 4:10 "For therefore we both labour and suffer reproach, because we trust in the living God, who is the Saviour of all men, especially of those that believe.".

Protestants spend so much time emphasizing the importance of us not having any reason to boast of our works.  But we do so in denial that Faith is itself a Work.  We consider it important that we do not think we contribute to our Salvation, yet will still think the Salvation of others is dependent on our Evangelism.

We're supposed to preach the Good News, not an Ultimatum.  We were told to Be A Witness, not to force our beliefs on people.  There is no Biblical Basis for door to door soul winning.

Here is one more Link I want to share.
http://theologicalscribbles.blogspot.com/2016/08/robin-parry-on-hope-for-israel-and.html

Thursday, April 12, 2018

Perpetua and Felicity

In light of KyleKallgrenBHH and his significant other's recent video lamenting the lack of Queer Women of Color representation, their review of The Watermelon Woman. And my desire to eventually spend more time on this blog deconstruction the European bias on how we view Church History.  I figure I should add my Surprising Church History on Sexuality series a post about Perpetua and Felicity.

Wikipedia Page
Passion_of_Saint_Perpetua,_Saint_Felicitas,_and_their_Companions

 Or course I don't have much to say that hasn't been said already.  So here are some Links.

http://qspirit.net/perpetua-felicity-same-sex-couples/

https://queeringthechurch.wordpress.com/tag/perpetua-and-felicity/

http://queering-the-church.blogspot.com/2012/03/ss-perpetua-and-felicity-martyrs-0703.html

The speculation of Montanism on the Wikipedia article I think is a product of Secessionists who want to think Montanists were the only Contuniations in the Early Church.  When in fact it's been repeatedly noted the objectors to Montanus were not denying the continuance of the Gift of Prophecy but criticism them for how they went about it.

The images below are taken from the first article.

Friday, April 6, 2018

The Heresies of Asia Minor

I'm annoyed by people appealing to the Early Church Fathers as if a doctrine being affirmed by them from very early on must make it valid, because The New Testament informs us heresies were emerging already in the first generation of The Church.

In Acts 20:16 Paul arrived in Ephesus and proceeded to warn them about false teachers who will emerge as soon as he leaves them.  Verses 29-31.
"For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock.  Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them.  Therefore watch, and remember, that by the space of three years I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears."
And later in 2 Timothy 1:15 Paul laments that all of Asia has departed from him.

In Revelation 2:2 the Ephesian Church being addressed is commended for rejecting False Apostles.  But the same false doctrines Ephesus resisted here we can infer were not so well resisted by the other churches, especially Pergamos.  Jesus refused to say anything bad about Smyrna because they were dying for their Faith, but even martyrs can be influenced by bad doctrines.

Now the Anti-Paul people insist Revelation is on the other side of this conflict, that Paul and his Clique are the False Apostles Jesus refereed to.  After all Paul said "All of Asia" seemingly not allowing Ephesus as an exception.

The Bible will sometimes use the word "all" hyperbolically when exceptions do exist.  That Ephesus is where Paul gave the warning, and also the only of the Seven Churches to also be recipients of a Paulian Epistle, is sufficient reason to expect them to be the exception.  Also Timothy himself was a Bishop in Ephesus when these letters were written so clearly he represents some support Paul still had there.

Meanwhile it could be a specific Church in Ephesus that John was in contact with being addressed.  It can be inferred that Ephesus is the city these False Apostles were operating in and that's why they're relevant to that message.

However it's also interesting that Jesus addresses them as the "Church of Ephesus" not the "Church in ____" as he did 5 of the 6 following Churches.  Could it be that the true Ephesian Church Paul founded was not actually in Ephesus anymore?  Remember he met with them as Miletus once.

I should mention that different definitions of what "Asia" meant in these kinds of contexts can create ambiguity about if Phyrgian locations (like Laodicea and the recipients of Colossians and maybe Philadephia) count as Asia. Some texts of 1 Timothy end with Paul saying he wrote that letter in Laodicea.  1 Peter 1:1 by not mentioning Phrygia at all is probably counting it as Asia, but language in Acts 16 seems to imply neither Phrygia or Mysia (where Pergamon was) count as Asia.  The Roman Province of Asia included all Seven cities however.  Polycrates seems to be counting Phrygian locations like Hierapolis and Laodicea as Asia, but since Pergamon and Thyatira aren't mentioned we don't know if he'd count them.

I think the more specific use of Asia is treating it as a synonym for Lydia (but with Coastal cities like Miletus, Ephesus and Smyrna added), which The Bible never uses as a location name, but in Acts 16 a woman from Thyatira is called Lydia in the KJV but the Greek means Lydian(of Lydia).  Thyatira was on the border between Lydia and Mysia.  Sardis was the capital of Ancient Lydia and the seat of a Proconsul under Rome.

I talked about the Apostles of Ephesus on this blog before, in that post mostly accepting the traditions at face value.  But now, given this direct Biblical Evidence of False Apostles in Ephesus, I should perhaps be just as skeptical of the traditions about John and the Marys going to Ephesus as I am of Peter going to Rome.  My theory that traditions of Mary Magdelene going to France are derivative of earlier traditions of her going to Ephesus because of Ephesian Christians migrating to France remains valid however.

It's interesting then how much of the alleged "Apostolic Succession" of the Early Church Fathers goes back to Asia Minor.  Polycarp, Ignatius and presumably Papias were all direct students of a "John" who was in Ephesus in the late first century.  Students of Polycarp founded the early church of Lyon in France, one of whom Irenaus was the mentor of Hipolytus an early Bishop of Rome and only Early Church precedent for Dispensationalist interpretations of Daniel 9 and 11.  Ignatius who is given much of the credit for the development of Early Church Hierarchy was a Bishop of Antioch so also played a role in spreading these doctrines beyond Asia Minor.

The Montanists also had their origin in Asia Minor, and were an influence on Tertulian the first Church Father to write in Latin and thus a major influence on later Latin Church writers like Augustine. 

Marcian also first emerged in Asia Minor.  Now at face value he's the opposite of departing from Paul, Marcian was Paul's biggest super fan.  But we see in 1 Corinthians that Paul was also annoyed by people saying they are "Of Paul" he would not like the term "Paulian Christianity".  Paul's warning in Acts 20 was of multiple heresies not just one, some emerging from without and some emerging from within.

Frankly the reason why so much confusion exists about the Nicolatians is because people keep turning to the Early Church Fathers opinions to identify them when in my view they were the Nicolatians and so in constant denial about who the Nicolatians really were and what they taught.

What Papias is quoted as saying about John The Presbyter I view as evidence that the original John of Ephesus was not an authentic Biblical John, but that his followers confused him with John later.

The canonocity of 2 John and 3 John were sometimes disputed in the Early Church.  Including attributing them to John the Presbyter.  But that early dispute gave them the same author, some today think these two Epistles were actually condemning each others authors.  That 3 John's description of Diotrephes fits the author of 2 John like a glove.  And so likewise the author of 3 John could be one of the people 2 John complains about.  Neither text actually identifies itself as having been written by a John.

But assuming they have the same Author, they still both show heretics had emerged within the presumed Johnian community.

Diotrephes has been seen as the first Monarchial Bishop.  Some early Church references do imply that in Asia Paul's Churches had many Elders who were all Bishops while Churches founded by "John" had one Bishop and multiple elders, a Structure elaborated upon by his student Ignatius.  So whether he wrote 2 John or not I think Diotrephes which means "nourished by Zeus" could be a name for the false John of Ephesus.

The origins of identifying the Beloved Disciple with the name of John are partly based on Polycrates statements about the John of Ephesus who he doesn't say was one of the 12.  He does say this John was a Priest (as in Kohen not as in Presbytr) possibly specifically a High Priest since he wore the Sacredotal Plate.  There was a High Priest of the Jerusalem Temple in the First Century named John, he was one of the sons of Ananias and probably the John kindred to the High Priest mentioned in Acts 4.  He served as High Priest twice both very briefly and we don't know what became of him afterwards.

Crenthius was one of the earliest Proto-Gnostics, and he spent time in Asia Minor.  Some also speculate he specifically was among those John's Epistles were written against.   What's distinct about Crenthius is that while Gnostic in many ways including separating the Demiurge from The Father.  He didn't view the Demiurge as Evil but rather taught we still had to follow The Law of Moses.  In a way that makes him a lot like Rob Skiba, who's an ardent Hebrew Roots believer but believes a lot of quasi Gnostic stuff.

The claim that Crenthius's Gospel was a version of Matthew I think must be wrong.  His doctrines make much more sense if he was focusing on Mark.  In fact I now think his Hersey was the origin of removing the last portion of Mark 16.

Melito the Eunuch who fell asleep in Sardis was also someone who seems to have had Legalistic tendencies.  The heresies Paul warned of I think are likely to include falling back into Legalism, after all the Ravening Wolves imagery suggests some of these false teachers will be fellow Benjamites based on Genesis 49.

This does not mean Asia Minor was the only source of Hersey.  Simon Magus I still believe was the real Peter of Rome, Justin Martyr was another mystic from Samaria who started his own school in Rome, and Tatian (possibly the first to teach Endless Torment and other Gnostic ideas) was a student of his. Justin was an early example of seeking to justify claiming that Socrates and Plato taught Christian ideas because they were in contact with the Logos.

I'm not trying to demonize anyone.  Some of the people I mentioned in this post were Martyred for their Faith in Jesus, and for that I firmly believe they won the Crown of Life no matter how flawed their doctrines were.  My point is simply that being an early belief of The Church doesn't make it a correct one.

There is a website called Church-History.Org which has some good information on it, but it says that Protestants were right to reject the Catholic Understanding of Tradition and Apostolic succession but were wrong to reject "Apostolic Tradition".   The problem is this Apostolic Tradition becomes exactly the same thing as the "Oral Torah" of Rabbinic Judaism aka The Pharisees Jesus preached against.  And it cites Ignatius as proof monarchical Church structure isn't heretical while admitting it's not supported by Scripture.

All references in the New Testament to "traditions" that seem positive are to teachings that became written down in the New Testament.  You need to remember when Paul was writing not even all 4 Gospels had been written down yet, and most of his Epistles predate Luke-Acts which were written while he was in Rome.  One of the things Jude refers to as a teaching from the Apostles is written down in 2 Peter, which some scholars think was written later then Jude.  But for the most part these "traditions" are what Jesus taught in The Gospels and what Peter and John taught in the first 11 chapters of Acts.

Thursday, March 29, 2018

Human Sacrifice in The Torah

So the New2Torah (Zachary Bauer) YouTube channel did a video about Human Sacrifice in The Torah in the context of The Messiah being an Atonement Sacrifice.

Then another video was made in response to it.  That second video I'm not able to embed directly it seems, so here is a Link.  Human Sacrifice and Messiah Answering New2Torah.

Bauer was definitely stupid to bring up the conspiracy theory that Isaiah 53 is removed from Jewish Bibles.  The latter video is also wrong however, no you can't get around that the Suffering Servant is an individual suffering for the sins of the people.  The Melchizedek Scroll of the Dead Sea Scrolls Interpreted it that way before the time of Christ.  The Talmud cites it as Messianic at least once in Sanhedrin 98b, the Leper Scholar.  The idea of it referring to the Nation doesn't show up till after 1000 AD.

Other criticisms the second video makes of the first are also valid, but not all.

For outside The Torah Zach should have referred to when David had seven sons of Saul hung on trees to appease the Gibeonites.  That is clear Hebrew Bible precedent for people being executed not for their own Sins but for the Sins of a blood Kinsman.  And five of them were maternal grandchildren interestingly.

The people in the latter video love to emphasize Repentance.  The Problem is I don't believe Yahuah is going to Save only those who Repent.  They love to point to Ezekiel 18, I point to Ezekiel 16 where even Sodom is promised to be restored.

The common claim that the Passover sacrifice isn't an Atonement Sacrifice I find to be rather semantic. The Passover is unique and doesn't fit into the other five general Sacrifice categories easily at all.  But it sure as heck resembles Atonement more then it does offering something to Yahuah just out of devotion.  God is carrying out a Judgment on Egypt for not letting Israel go, and putting The Blood on the Doorpost protects your Household from that Judgment.  The Levitical Atonement Sacrifices also involved Covering things with The Blood.  The Passover Lamb covers a Household not an individual, Jesus was offered for the Household of Adam.

The people in the second video say that Atonement Sacrifices have to be female, I don't know where they got that.  The Yom Kippur Sacrifice is a male Goat in Leviticus 16.  Leviticus 4:3 requires a male Bullock to Atone for the Sin of a Priest, and Leviticus 4:14 and Numbers 15:24 require it to be a male Bullock and/or male kid of the Goats if it's offered on behalf of the Community.  And Leviticus 4:22-23 says if a Nasi sins the Atonement offering has to be a male of the Goats.  And of course The Passover had to be a male.

The Trespass offering in Leviticus 5 is what requires a Female.  However Jesus defined the Sins of Humanity as unknowing sins on The Cross.  But at any rate, I believe Jesus was ultimately both male and female.  Jesus also fulfilled the Red Heifer offering by being killed on the Mount of Olives, "without the Camp".

The second Video also got persnickety about saying you don't Anoint a Sacrificial Offering.  You know Torah Only people love to say the only person who's Anointed in the Torah is the Priest, there is no Anointing of Kings.  Jesus is both the Offering and the one Making the Offering.  The Torah does say to anoint the Wafers of Unleavened Bread.  Now they made it sound like your forbidden to Anoint the animal, but the Torah doesn't say that either.

Both Isaac and Joseph play the role of a sacrificial offering in narratives even though they weren't literally.

Now here is a subject many are uncomfortable with.  Technically Yahuah demands Human Sacrifice in The Torah of all maternal firstborns.

Exodus 22:29-30.
"Thou shalt not delay to offer the first of thy ripe fruits, and of thy liquors: the firstborn of thy sons shalt thou give unto me.  Likewise shalt thou do with thine oxen, and with thy sheep: seven days it shall be with his dam; on the eighth day thou shalt give it me."
However this situation is clarified in Numbers 18:15-17.
"Every thing that openeth the matrix in all flesh, which they bring unto Yahuah, whether it be of men or beasts, shall be thine: nevertheless the firstborn of man shalt thou surely redeem, and the firstling of unclean beasts shalt thou redeem.  And those that are to be redeemed from a month old shalt thou redeem, according to thine estimation, for the money of five shekels, after the shekel of the sanctuary, which is twenty gerahs.  But the firstling of a bullock, or the firstling of a sheep, or the firstling of a goat, thou shalt not redeem; they are holy: thou shalt sprinkle their blood upon the altar, and shalt burn their fat for an offering made by fire, for a sweet savour unto Yahuah."
This is not about the Firstborns losing their Priestly status to the Levites, Numbers 3:12 dealt with that.  This is specifically about a demand for every First Born to be Sacrificed to Yahuah.

It's interesting that Humans are distinguished from unclean animals, even though when viewed as animals we lack both requirements for being Levitically clean.  Humans aren't animals however.  With animals these physical characteristics of cleanness are merely symbolic representations of moral purity.  The only thing keeping most Humans from being an acceptable Sacrifice is being Sinful.  Only someone without Sin can truly Atone for the Sins of another.

Moses' blessing on Joseph is the foundation of the Messiah Ben Joseph doctrine.  Deuteronomy 33:17 says.
"His glory is like the firstling of his bullock, and his horns are like the horns of unicorns: with them he shall push the people together to the ends of the earth: and they are the ten thousands of Ephraim, and they are the thousands of Manasseh."
The Hebrew words for firstling and Bullock here are the same as in Numbers 18:17.  It was firmly established in the minds of all Israelites that every Firstling Bullock was to be Sacrificed, no exceptions.  So this passage has been taken even by non Christians as saying someone of Joseph will be sacrificed and then risen again (the "Unicorn" representing him Resurrected), hence the Messiah Ben Joseph tradition.

The context is about Maternal Firstborns.  Galilee in NT times wasn't just Naphtali anymore. I think Nazareth was possibly actually Jezreel, a site that can potentially be linked to Manasseh.  And when reading about Hezekiah's Passover it becomes clear plenty of Manasseh was still left behind after the Captivity.

Manasseh was the firstborn of Asenath and Joseph was the firstborn of Rachel.  It's interesting that Matthew 1:25 and Luke 2:7 both emphasize that Jesus was the Firstborn of Mary even though the Virgin Birth already made that obvious.

And hey, I made that case without even addressing the awkward issue of Jephthah's Daughter.

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

I don't think the person Paul calls Kepha/Kephas is Simon Peter.

I know that in John 1:42 Simon is called Kephas and we're told that means Petros.  But the Protestant understanding of Petras and Petros is that Jesus is the Eben/Petra and all of us believers are Petron carved out of him.

Paul's Epistles use the name Peter only in Galatians, but he also uses Kephas once there.

In Galatians 2 he refers to Peter in verses 7 and 8, then to James, Cephas and John in verse 9, then to Peter again in verses 11 and 14.  Reading through the whole chapter it seems odd to me that he would this one time use a different name.

Now comparing to the Gospels, you might feel compelled to say Galatians 2:9 is like the verses that refer to Peter, James and John.  But Paul names them in a different order, in those verses Peter was always first.  And Paul is not contradicting Peter's primacy, the prior two verses just defined Peter as being in charge of bringing The Gospel to the Circumcision.  Also the James in this verse isn't the Son of Zebedee since it's about Acts 15 and he was Martyred in chapter 12.

It seems more likely that after already talking about Peter this verse is then listing other Pillars of the Church in Jerusalem.

The rest of Paul's references to Kephas are in 1 Corinthians.  1:12 and 3:22 refer to Paul himself, Apollos and Kepha being people who have fans in Corinth who are having fandom rivalries with each other, and Paul reminds them we're all supposed to be focused on Christ.

Chapter 15 is the most defining identifying characteristic of this Kepha however.   In verses 4 and 5 he says.
And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures: And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
He didn't say "then the rest of the twelve".  Even without comparing this to other sources on the Resurrection, it clearly seems to be saying Kepha is not one of the Twelve.

Paul's list of Eye Witnesses to the Resurrection is not complete, but that who he does list is chronological is part of his point, he defines himself as the least of the apostles in part because he was the last eye witness to the Resurrection.

In The Gospel accounts, Peter does not see the risen Jesus till about the same time most of the Twelve do.  Peter enters the Empty Tomb, but that's not seeing the risen Jesus.  The defining characteristic of Kepha in 1 Corinthians 15:5 is being the first Eye Witness to the Resurrection.

Matthew 28 and Luke 24 tell us the Women who found the Tomb Empty saw the risen Jesus before the 12.  And Mark 16:9 and John 20 further clarify that the individual first eye witness of The Resurrection was Mary Magdalene.

Now I know this observation might seem like music to the ears of the DaVinci Code style conspiracy theorists, who'll say Paul is an older source so this is evidence that the Church later gave to Peter a title that belonged to Mary Magdalene.  But as I already pointed out, Paul does give primacy to Peter and discourages those who place too much importance on Kepha or himself or any other Apostle.

Since Magdalene probably comes from Migdol which means Tower, perhaps it refers to a stone tower?

Update March 27th 2024: I've now argued in favor of now viewing Mary as The Beloved Disciple.  

Also I've noticed that in 1 Corinthians 1:12 and 15:4-5 the Greek Textus Receptus says Cepha with no S on the end, that makes it arguably Grammatically Feminine.

I'm going to do something I used to be less willing to do and argue there has been textual corruption.  And then originally Cephas was only used in 1 John and all Paul's references are to Cepha.  Thus Cephas is Peter but Cepha is Mary.

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

The Books of Chronicles versus Samuel and Kings

When it comes to skeptics looking for alleged Bible Contradictions, The Book (they were one book originally) of Chronicles providing an alternate account of the History of the Kingdom Period is perhaps second only to the parallel Gospel record.

I do feel there are no irreconcilable differences in terms of what the two accounts say happened. I've already talked about The Widow's Son and Jehosheba.  And the Genealogy of Rehoboam's Queen in a Song of Songs post.  As far as whether David used Silver or Gold to buy the land of the threshing floor, the accounts are specific in what they say, the Gold bought the land itself and the Silver everything on the land.

What my mind has been contemplating is a pretty clear thematic difference in point of view.  The Gospels have different things they emphasize, but never leading to the conclusion they are trying to send a totally different message.  With Chronicles it does sometimes seem that way.

We can view these as different points of view where one is less correct then the other, without completely rejecting either as part of God's Word.  It may be God wants us to know and learn from this other POV. 2 Timothy 2:15 talks about rightly dividing the word of truth.  We often talk about needing two witnesses to build doctrine, but don't fully think about the implications of when there isn't a confirming witness.

The first apparent example of this is the origin of the Samaritans.

2 Kings 17 tells us Assyria after deporting seemingly all of the Northern Kingdom settled some people from Northern Mesopotamia in their old land.  The newcomers worshiped their old idols which caused problems, then Assyria gives them a Priest of Jeroboam's Priesthood who teaches them to worship Jeroboam's Idols.  Later in 2 Kings 23:15 Josiah destroys the altar at Bethel which ends Idolatry in the region.  But the point still remains that the Samaritans descend from foreigners.

2 Chronicles does not contain it's own version of the 2 Kings 17 narratives, it does refer to Josiah destroying idols but doesn't single out Bethel.  However in chapter 30 we learn that some remnants of the northern kingdom's population were still there during the reign of Hezekiah who invited them to his Passover celebration.  Some mocked the invitation, but others accepted, with people of Manasseh and Ephraim being mentioned in both groups.  Now the text of 2 Chronicles isn't explicitly saying this is where the Samaritans come from, but the implication could to be they come from those who rejected it.

Now these accounts can both be perfectly true, in fact both being true fits best what the Assyrian inscriptions say, they didn't deport everyone just a lot, this policy was about mixing their population.

But the point is Kings and Chronicles choose different things to emphasize.  And on this thematic disagreement, the New Testament takes a side. 

When Jesus sent the 70 Disciples on their first training missionary mission, He tells them to go only to the Children of Israel and not Gentiles or Samaritans, showing he didn't count them as Israelites.  Later at the true Great Commission the Samaritans are included as are the gentiles.  (Ezra and Nehemiah also seem to confirm the Kings viewpoint.)  

[Update May 9th 2026: I've since changed my mind entirely about 2 Kings 17's relevance to the Samaritans.]

Matthew's genealogy uses the final form of the name of Salmon that Ruth uses, not Salma from 1 Chronicles 2.

One might argue Matthew not including King Manasseh among the generations skipped is an influence of Chronicles, since only Chronicles records his repentance, based on Kings alone you'd think he's the worst most irredeemable villain of the Kingdom Period.  Bur he's not the only Bad King who's name is still included.

And 1 Chronicles 2 may be the only basis for putting a Recab in David's genealogy (Matthew is not saying Rahab the Harlot married Salmon, her name is Raab in New Testament texts).  But that's about it for possible New Testament dependence on Chronicles, one genealogy which for at least one name is also going against Chronicles.

The only point where a New Testament author can be made to look like they're directly quoting  Chronicles, is really them and Chronicles quoting the same Davidic Psalm.  Of course that is true of apparent New Testament quotations of Samuel as well.  And the only NT quotes of Kings is of Elijah speaking.  Jesus quoted The Torah and Prophets (Acts 2 calls David a Prophet), but it can maybe be argued that the New Testament doesn't want us to take the histories in the Kingdom period books at entirely face value.

The Chronicles account is also responsible for much of the confusion about Tarshish.  The only verses making it sound like Tarshish was the destination of naval adventures from the Red Sea port are in 2 Chronicles in 9:21 and 20:36-37.  Their equivalent passages in 1 Kings 10:11&22 and 2 Kings 22:48 make clear that Ophir in Yemen was the destination, but the ships are called ships of Tarshish because they were modeled after Tarshish ships, possibly with cooperation from Tarshish.

This may not be entirely wrong, looking at things like how Native Americans became Indians, maybe at some point Israelites started calling this place Tarshish even though it really wasn't because that's what they called the ships they used to get there.  But Jonah makes clear that Tarshish is really accessed via the the Mediterranean port at Joppa. 

But this confusion has been useful for people who don't find the mainstream views of Tarshish romantic enough, wanting to make it Briton, or Atlantis, or India, or Japan, and I'd even contemplated making them the Olmecs in the past.  But I've abandoned those speculations now.

What's even more interesting is Solomon.  Chronicles has no equivalent to 1 Kings 11.  Which is the first of a few facts suggesting it has a generally more apologetic attitude towards Solomon.  And returning to the subject of the New Testament taking sides, I did a post on how the New Testament is rather dismissive of Solomon.

By leaving out the murder of Urias and including the repentance of Manasseh, Chronicles is arguably being more apologetic to the Davidic Kings in general.  But the moral point is David and Manasseh repented, Solomon never repented of his 1 Kings 11 sins.

1 Kings 4 tells us Solomon went to Sacrifice at the "Great High Place" at Gibeon, elsewhere Kings consistently refers to High Places as inherently bad. Many commentators on this say it shows God's mercy that he answers Solomon's prayer here in-spite of this, and I can't say I exactly disagree with that.

But when 2 Chronicles 1 records the same event, it also identifies Gibeon and calls it a High Place, but adds that this was where the Tabernacle of Moses was.  Other passages in the books of Chronicles further back up the Tabernacle being here for awhile.  But Samuel and Kings never place the Tabernacle at Gibeon, they don't contradict it being here at this time, and do earlier place it at Nob (in an event Jesus refers to) which is often speculated to be either close by or another name for the same place.  But the tone in Kings seems to be that Solomon was in error coming here, while Chronicles wants to justify it.  And Kings tells us Abiathar the priest who survived the Nob massacre lived at Anathoth, and that Abiathar later was working with Joab and Adonijah in their attempted coup, another story Chronicles leaves out.

In fact Samuel-Kings also links a Great Stone at Gibeon to Absalom and Amasa's rebellion.

Even if the physical Tabernacle built by Moses was there, it was violating the Torah itself by being on a High Place.  And also the Ark wasn't here, it was brought by David to first Zion and then Jerusalem.  Psalm 132 tells us David's Tabernacle was at Ephratha.

And then there is how only 2 Chronicles 3:1 applies the name of Moriah to where Ornan's threshing floor was and where Solomon's Temple was built.  Again this Moriah could be not the same hill as Genesis 22:2 and still not be wrong, Solomon may have given the name of Moriah to the hill to evoke that event.

Tuesday, March 13, 2018

Baptism and the Mikveh

One of the trends of the Hebrew Roots movement is to suggest a connection between New Testament Baptism and the Jewish Mikveh custom.  Thing is, even though I'm someone who wants to explain the New Testament via the Hebrew Bible and Hebrew culture as much as possible, I've been skeptical of this one.

For one, the Mikveh as it's traditionally thought of now is not very supported by the Hebrew Bible, it's mostly a Greco-Roman/Second Temple era development.  There is certainly no verse that uses the word Mikveh in a way that it would make sense to translate it Baptism or Baptize.  There are two Hebrew words sometimes translated wash, washed or bathe in verses cited as being Mikveh relevant.  Of those rachats is the one that I think would be used if the Hebrew Bible described something like Baptism, since it's meaning implies immersion, the other one to consider is kabac but that word is usually about washing cloths.

Secondly, the Mikveh as it had become by New Testament times was done in in-door or at least man made pools of water.  Baptism as presented in the New Testament is done in running water, in rivers.  Now one could say it fits the New Testament theme of rejecting institutionalized religion to move the Mikveh to an outdoor natural water source.  But that would need other evidence.

The Torah/TNAK basis for the Mikveh are all pretty much verses about ritual cleansing.  Which kind of does come up in the New Testament as a separate issue from Baptism, like when Jesus (seemingly) didn't wash his hands in Luke 11:38 and Mark 7.  

Of course another famous New Testament custom connected to this Hebrew word is Foot Washing, Torah references to Foot Washing also use rachats.

It seems the Mishna says the ritual cleansing related to the Red Heifer in Numbers 19 required running water and can't be done in a Mikveh.  But The Torah itself gives no such indication that it has stricter rules.

But even in Rabbinic and Modern Jewish sources, there are no references to Mikvehs being about Repentance as John's Baptism was.

There are two cited uses of the Mikveh that sound to Christians like they make it an attractive analogy for Baptism.  But neither of them have a basis in The Torah or any other part of the Hebrew Bible.

One is it being done as part of a gentile proselyte converting to Judaism.  That seems like what the Baptisms in Acts were all about.  But The Hebrew Bible doesn't call for it, rather the only ritual associated with an outsider becoming an Israelite is Circumcision.  Which of course brings us to the theory about Baptism the Hebrew Roots people hate, that it's meant to replace Circumcision.  Now I'm not convinced of that theory either, but I do believe Christians don't have to be Circumcised.

The other is a claim that it's done by a Bride some time between Espousal and the Wedding.  I could do a whole post on why I'm annoyed at Christians building doctrine on Extra-Biblical Jewish Wedding Customs.  But in this case, not only is this not Biblical but Wikipedia is unaware of it being one of the uses of the Mikveh at all, so this might be something some Christians just imagined.

Michael Rood likes to make it sound like the Israelites were "Mikvehed" in Exodus 19, during the preparation for the giving of The Law.  But actually only their cloths are refereed to as being washed there.

What I have noticed on my own while looking into this issue is that a ritual washing was part of consecrating Aaron and his sons as Priests in Exodus 29:4 and 40:12, and also Leviticus 8:6.  And that makes me think of the doctrine of the Priesthood of all Believers.  And all the other aspects of this consecration ceremony revolved around the Sacrifice which isn't needed anymore.

And this seems to be the only rachats ritual to involve the person in question being "washed" by someone else rather then washing themselves.  Leviticus clarifies Moses did it originally but going forward it's probably implied new Priests are initiated by people already Priests.  So Jesus is Baptized partly because He's our High Priest, and then we are Baptized because of the Priesthood of All Believers.

Baptists are often hostile to these kinds of Hebrew Roots style explanations for New Testament ideas, but in this case it actually does help their position.  The more mainstream view that Baptism simply replaces Circumcision is a core part of the argument for Pedobaptism.  But if it's instead about initiation into the Priesthood of all Believers then that naturally supports Believers Baptism (even Aaron's Sons had already been adults for awhile in Exodus 29, Aaron was older then Moses making him over 80 at the Exodus so it's highly unlikely his kids weren't at least 30).  The Priesthood of all Believers is also foundational to Congregational Polity another core doctrine of the Baptist movement, so connecting it to Baptism is like Poetry it Rhymes.

Speaking of being 30, in Numbers 4 the age of 30 seems to be presented as when Levites began their service in the Tabernacle, 1 Chronicles 23:3 reaffirms that.  And low and behold Jesus came to John to be Baptized when he was about 30 years old.  Perhaps this is why Luke considered John's Kohen Heritage important to emphasize, for both his mother and father.

Whether or not there is some connection between the Mikveh and Baptism.  People like Michael Rood using the word Mikveh as a "translation" of Baptism when they refer to the New Testament doctrine I find very misleading, and doing that when quoting the New Testament is just plain wrong.