In the past I've put all my eggs in the Hospitality/Immigration argument, and that is still an important symptom of their disease. But it's verse 49 of Ezekiel's 16th Chapter that gives us the full diagnosis.
"Moreover this was the sin of thy sister Sodom, pride: she and her daughters lived in pleasure, in fullness of bread in abundance: this belonged to her and her daughters, and they helped not the hand of the poor and needy."
There is no getting around that this is a condemnation of Wealth Hording, that the kind of people who talk this way today are Communists and Socialists.
And it's not addressing individual Rich People who don't voluntarily give to the Poor. It's about Sodom as a society.
References to Sodom in Isaiah and Jeremiah also stress it being tied to their greed and wealth. I argued on my Prophecy Blog that the Whoredom of Babylon is Capitalism, and Eschatological prophecies of Babylon do evoke Sodom.
Jude 7 when talking about Sodom uses the word "Pornea" which the KJV translates "Fornication", it's actually a word for Prostitution but that unlike some other Greek words for Prostitution is stressing specifically the economic aspect of it, coming from a root which means "to sell". Likewise in Ezekiel 16 the three times the KJV refers to "Fornication" it's the exact same words the KJV in this same chapter elsewhere translates whoredom, whore and harlot. I believe some Biblical references to "whoredom" aren't about sex at all.
And the issue of Sodom being in-hospitable to immigrants is not unrelated, travelers and refuges are also needy and poor. And Capitalists love to use nativist sentiments to get the poor citizens to blame the immigrants for the problems that are actually Capitalism's fault.
Ironically some Marxists might say I'm being Anachronistic here since we all know Capitalism didn't exist till after the Reformation, at the very soonest. But the thing is part of why I'm not a Marxist is that I disagree with the Marxist view of history. I know some Breadtubers love to stress how young Capitalism is in response to Conservatives arguing that it's "Natural", but we can't deny Patriarchy has been a thing for all of Human history. How about when addressing Conservative Christians we remind them that The Church is supposed to be "contrary to nature" (Para Phusis) according to Romans 11.
Even if I were to concede that Feudalism is distinct from Capitalism, when I look at Ancient Rome ("Republican" Rome at least) it's hard for me not to see it as Capitalist with it's wealthy land owners and the way it's "Democracy" was so thoroughly jerrymandered against the urban poor. And I see similar Capitalism in Carthage and at least some of the City-States of Greece.
Capitalism has different forms, from Mercantilism to industrial Capitalism, from Classical Liberalism to Neo-Liberalism, from Jeffersonianism to Hamiltonianism. Some reactionaries claim to hate Capitalism as much as they do Communism while still being called Capitalists by Communists.
During the Middle Ages I believe Capitalism was continued by Venice and perhaps some other Italian coastal City-States. Then after the Reformation opened the door for upheavals in some parts of Europe the city of Amsterdam and other northern ports started being influenced by the Venetians they traded with. And then England started borrowing from both Amsterdam and Venice as it started striving to be a Sea Power under Henry VIII, Elizabeth and the Stuarts.
Some writers have argued Protastantism helped cause Capitalism. But it's really one major school of Protestantism, the "Reformed Tradition" of Zwingly that later split into Calvinist and Arminian camps. Luther actually loved Feudalism and wanted to make it stronger rather then weaker. And the Anabaptists like the Taborite and John Ball before the Reformation were Communists. But to the point I'm making here, it can be argued that Venetian theologians had an overlooked influence on the early Reformation even though they nominally stayed Catholic through men like Gasparo Continari.
Roman Capitalism came from the Greeks and also Carthage who's Trade networks Rome absorbed as they conquered it. Carthage and Greece were both influenced by the Phoenicians, a people The Bible refers to as Sidonians who's major cities were first Sidon and later Tyre. Ezekiel 27 is perhaps just as much a description of Capitalism as Ezekiel 16 is. The Sidonians were the Canaanites of Lebanon and Sodom is also mentioned when talking about the Canaanites in Genesis 10. In Ezekiel 16 God's criticism of Jerusalem (which is Sodom's Sin but now worse) also involved Him spiritually calling them Jebusites and Amorites.
Capitalism is the Socio-Economic Vice of the Canaanites, while Feudalism came from Egypt.
No comments:
Post a Comment