[Update: I'm not a Libertarian anymore.]
All of my posts on this Blog are meant to be Conversation Starters. I never want to be the final word on any topic. I'm trying to put ideas out there that hopefully others more knowledgeable and skilled then me can expand on.
Wednesday, January 21, 2015
Friday, December 26, 2014
The Bible on Traditional Gender Roles
Men and Women are different, both physically and mentally. And those differences existed from the creation of distinct genders for humanity in Genesis 2. But the dividing of men and women into different roles in society, especially the notion that men are supposed to be in charge, is purely the product of The Fall in Genesis 3.
In Genesis 2 the Woman is created to be Adam's "Helper" or "Helpmeet". Adam may have been created first but they were still meant to be equals. It is not until Genesis 3:16 that God tells her "I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee."
On this side of the cross The Church should be working to restore things to how God intended, though we do so knowing that won't be fully successful until Jesus returns and sets up his Kingdom.
But still we should be working towards that as much as possible. That's why good Christians oppose Slavery in-spite of the Torah's tolerance of it. And why I've argued elsewhere we should oppose Capital Punishment, even though it was an important part of The Law.
The Law of Moses does codify many traditional gender role related laws (but not in the same way most other nations did). But New Testament believers are not under The Law. And even in the Old Testament we had people like Deborah.
Ezekiel's description of the future Messianic Temple has no separate Court of Women just as it no longer has a separate court for Gentiles. Likewise Galatians 3:28 says "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus."
I have another post arguing against those who say women cannot be Pastors/Preachers.
The verses some people dwell on about cross dressing are directed at specific pagan ritual practices involving cross dressing. They were not meant to be taken as legalistically as they are today by many pastors who want to shame women for simply wearing pants rather then skirts/dresses. I notice that particular phraseisim isn't as popular in colder states, like Wisconsin where I live.
The extent to which traditional gender roles are still endorsed in The New Testament (and I believe even NT instructions we shouldn't be legalistic about), are entirely limited to to the relationship between Husband and Wife. Those verses exist purely for the typological application to the relationship between Christ and The Church. Point is, as long as your unmarried those verses have no relevance to you and your interactions with people of the opposite gender, weather your male or female. And if you are married they're relevant only to your relationship with your spouse. Do not go around judging other couples or individuals.
The New Testament certainly doesn't forbid women to be unmarried. Nor does it forbid women, married or not, from having careers or doing God's work outside the household.
In Genesis 2 the Woman is created to be Adam's "Helper" or "Helpmeet". Adam may have been created first but they were still meant to be equals. It is not until Genesis 3:16 that God tells her "I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee."
On this side of the cross The Church should be working to restore things to how God intended, though we do so knowing that won't be fully successful until Jesus returns and sets up his Kingdom.
But still we should be working towards that as much as possible. That's why good Christians oppose Slavery in-spite of the Torah's tolerance of it. And why I've argued elsewhere we should oppose Capital Punishment, even though it was an important part of The Law.
The Law of Moses does codify many traditional gender role related laws (but not in the same way most other nations did). But New Testament believers are not under The Law. And even in the Old Testament we had people like Deborah.
Ezekiel's description of the future Messianic Temple has no separate Court of Women just as it no longer has a separate court for Gentiles. Likewise Galatians 3:28 says "There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus."
I have another post arguing against those who say women cannot be Pastors/Preachers.
The verses some people dwell on about cross dressing are directed at specific pagan ritual practices involving cross dressing. They were not meant to be taken as legalistically as they are today by many pastors who want to shame women for simply wearing pants rather then skirts/dresses. I notice that particular phraseisim isn't as popular in colder states, like Wisconsin where I live.
The extent to which traditional gender roles are still endorsed in The New Testament (and I believe even NT instructions we shouldn't be legalistic about), are entirely limited to to the relationship between Husband and Wife. Those verses exist purely for the typological application to the relationship between Christ and The Church. Point is, as long as your unmarried those verses have no relevance to you and your interactions with people of the opposite gender, weather your male or female. And if you are married they're relevant only to your relationship with your spouse. Do not go around judging other couples or individuals.
The New Testament certainly doesn't forbid women to be unmarried. Nor does it forbid women, married or not, from having careers or doing God's work outside the household.
Tuesday, October 28, 2014
Questioning someones Salvation based on how much they agree with your interpretation of The Bible
Some fellow believers in Eternal Security won't fall into the trap of questioning someone's Salvation based on behavior. But they may insist that a Truly Saved person won't hold views that disagree with The Bible.
They base it mainly on verses like "Everyone who is of the Truth hears my voice" in John 18.or John 8:47 "He that is of God heareth God's words: ye therefore hear them not, because ye are not of God.".
The danger of this view is that it's very strongly based on opinion. Yes I believe every Biblical question has only one correct answer. But the Brain is still of the Flesh. The Faith that saves is of the Heart, not an intellectual belief. The thief on the Cross didn't even expect his Belief would save him.
Basically this view says a Saved person can be mistaken on something at first, but if you show them from The Word the truth and they don't believe it they aren't Saved. They may add that a Saved person can be stubborn on maybe 1 or 2 issues, but if they do it repeatedly they're not Saved.
The main Pastor I saw teaching this, tied into it his view that the Disciples (most anyway, not Judas who was never Saved) were already Saved all through Jesus' ministry. Saying they were Saved before Jesus called them. Well the Disciples repeatedly refused to accept what Jesus told them, that he had to be killed and rise again.
In my view, if someone outright doesn't care what The Bible says then maybe it can be logical to question their Salvation. But if they clearly care what it says, if they're doing mental gymnastic to get around a clear teaching. Or just insisting that you must be misusing that verse without an argument at all, then it sounds to me like they are hearing The Word, just struggling with accepting it like the Disciples did.
I think It's pretty difficult for an unsaved person to even believe The Bible is infallible. One might say they view it as God's Word but have some qualifiers to that which make it fall short of true infallibility.
The World makes it pretty hard to simply see The Bible as Infallible. Historically when someone has come to the conclusion that The Bible is a perfect book for purely logical reasons, they get Saved almost immediately.
Reason why I'm so annoyed about all these tests Christians throw out to prove someone isn't Saved, is that the Bible is far less ambiguous on what Proves someone IS Saved.
1 John 4:2 says " Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God". And verse 15 says "Whosoever shall confess that Jesus is the Son of God, God dwelleth in him, and he in God.".
Romans 10 says "All who call upon the name of The Lord shall be Saved" no qualifying statements.
Those who take the verses on "knowing a tree by it's fruits" to say an Unfruitful Christians can't be saved are misunderstanding the verse. BUT if a believer has borne visible Good Fruit, then that person's Salvation certainly should not be questioned.
I would also never question the Salvation of anyone who died for their Faith in Jesus. Yet many Catholics have done that, especially during the French Revolution. And none are more doctrinally wrong then Catholics.
They base it mainly on verses like "Everyone who is of the Truth hears my voice" in John 18.or John 8:47 "He that is of God heareth God's words: ye therefore hear them not, because ye are not of God.".
The danger of this view is that it's very strongly based on opinion. Yes I believe every Biblical question has only one correct answer. But the Brain is still of the Flesh. The Faith that saves is of the Heart, not an intellectual belief. The thief on the Cross didn't even expect his Belief would save him.
Basically this view says a Saved person can be mistaken on something at first, but if you show them from The Word the truth and they don't believe it they aren't Saved. They may add that a Saved person can be stubborn on maybe 1 or 2 issues, but if they do it repeatedly they're not Saved.
The main Pastor I saw teaching this, tied into it his view that the Disciples (most anyway, not Judas who was never Saved) were already Saved all through Jesus' ministry. Saying they were Saved before Jesus called them. Well the Disciples repeatedly refused to accept what Jesus told them, that he had to be killed and rise again.
In my view, if someone outright doesn't care what The Bible says then maybe it can be logical to question their Salvation. But if they clearly care what it says, if they're doing mental gymnastic to get around a clear teaching. Or just insisting that you must be misusing that verse without an argument at all, then it sounds to me like they are hearing The Word, just struggling with accepting it like the Disciples did.
I think It's pretty difficult for an unsaved person to even believe The Bible is infallible. One might say they view it as God's Word but have some qualifiers to that which make it fall short of true infallibility.
The World makes it pretty hard to simply see The Bible as Infallible. Historically when someone has come to the conclusion that The Bible is a perfect book for purely logical reasons, they get Saved almost immediately.
Reason why I'm so annoyed about all these tests Christians throw out to prove someone isn't Saved, is that the Bible is far less ambiguous on what Proves someone IS Saved.
1 John 4:2 says " Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God". And verse 15 says "Whosoever shall confess that Jesus is the Son of God, God dwelleth in him, and he in God.".
Romans 10 says "All who call upon the name of The Lord shall be Saved" no qualifying statements.
1 Corinthians 12:3 says "that no man can say that Jesus is the Lord, but by the Holy Ghost.".
Those who take the verses on "knowing a tree by it's fruits" to say an Unfruitful Christians can't be saved are misunderstanding the verse. BUT if a believer has borne visible Good Fruit, then that person's Salvation certainly should not be questioned.
I would also never question the Salvation of anyone who died for their Faith in Jesus. Yet many Catholics have done that, especially during the French Revolution. And none are more doctrinally wrong then Catholics.
Sunday, October 26, 2014
Outer Darkness is Outside New Jerusalem
I've mentioned that view of mine before, why do I believe that?
For starters the term is only used in Parables. You have to be careful building Doctrine off Parables, things aren't always what they seem.
First of all, to fellow believers in Eternal Security (True Eternal Security, without any Calvinist or Repentance based qualifiers) who are uncomfortable with this suggestion for whatever reason, read Matthew carefully. There is no way to get away with saying the people Jesus describes being sent there were never saved. In 22:13, 24:51 and 25:30 they are servants, the unsaved are never servants of God, they're in rebellion against him. The people sent there are contrasted not with all believers but those who receive rewards based on their works.
And in 8:12 they're among the "children of the kingdom". Most people want to in this context make that phrase refer to Israel. But it's only other usage in Matthew 13 clearly identifies them as the Saved.
Now the frequently linked "Wailing and Gnashing of Teeth" is an idiom of grief and sorrow. That is sometimes likened to the Judgment of the Unsaved (I never think it's actually Hell directly), like in it's one appearance in Mark. But it certainly is not required to always be in that context.
Jude 13 also refers to the people being in the darkness of blackness forever but not being tormented.
It can make sense to describe damnation as "Outer Darkness" if you accept the Un-Biblical yet popular idea that Hell or the Lake of Fire is "eternal separation from God". But not if you believe what The Bible says. Revelation 14:10 describes the Lake of Fire as being in God's presence. The fire and brimstone that burns the damned emanates from God's presence in Isaiah 30:33 and II Thessalonians 1:8-9. God Himself is called a consuming fire in Deuteronomy 4:24 and Hebrews 12:29. And Deuteronomy 32:22 also defined the fire of judgment as coming from God. So it's neither "outer" nor "darkness".
New Jerusalem is defined as where the Light is in Revelation 21:23-25. Then verse 26 contradicts those who insist all the Saved are the Lambs Wife, it says there are Nations of the Saved outside New Jerusalem. The people listed here though still get to come to New Jerusalem to worship it seems.
Revelation 22:5 returns to discussing how New Jerusalem is where the Light is.
People who are Universalists of some kind like to point to Revelation 22:15, where it seems to them like the same people sent into the Lake of Fire earlier are now merely outside The City. And you can't argue the Lake of Fire is outside the City because I already showed it is The Presence of God.
People who teach Salvation can be lost (or the fifth point of Calvinism/false repentance doctrine) love to use 1 Corinthians 6:9-10, Galatians 5:21 and Ephesians 5:5. All these are vice lists warning that those who continue in those sins will not Inherit the Kingdom, and they're clearly warnings to already Saved Believers. But they do not say salvation can be lost, only inheritance. Like the Prodigal Son a Believer can squander his inheritance but he'll never lose his Sonship. They are the believers not allowed to enter New Jerusalem.
The Bema Judgment will not be a Judgment where anyone is really scolded or punished for their Sins. It is a handing out of Rewards only. But one of those Rewards is for keeping your Flesh under control, the Imperishable or Incorruptible Crown.
Luke 8's account of the Parable of the Sower divides people who hear the word into four groups in verses 12-15. Only the first, those who never believed, are described as unsaved. There are people who will believe for a little while and fall way, I discussed Hebrews 6 elsewhere. Also there are those that are believers till the end but are also very worldly. And then those that are fruitful. Only the Fruitful I think will really be New Jerusalem.
For starters the term is only used in Parables. You have to be careful building Doctrine off Parables, things aren't always what they seem.
First of all, to fellow believers in Eternal Security (True Eternal Security, without any Calvinist or Repentance based qualifiers) who are uncomfortable with this suggestion for whatever reason, read Matthew carefully. There is no way to get away with saying the people Jesus describes being sent there were never saved. In 22:13, 24:51 and 25:30 they are servants, the unsaved are never servants of God, they're in rebellion against him. The people sent there are contrasted not with all believers but those who receive rewards based on their works.
And in 8:12 they're among the "children of the kingdom". Most people want to in this context make that phrase refer to Israel. But it's only other usage in Matthew 13 clearly identifies them as the Saved.
Now the frequently linked "Wailing and Gnashing of Teeth" is an idiom of grief and sorrow. That is sometimes likened to the Judgment of the Unsaved (I never think it's actually Hell directly), like in it's one appearance in Mark. But it certainly is not required to always be in that context.
Jude 13 also refers to the people being in the darkness of blackness forever but not being tormented.
It can make sense to describe damnation as "Outer Darkness" if you accept the Un-Biblical yet popular idea that Hell or the Lake of Fire is "eternal separation from God". But not if you believe what The Bible says. Revelation 14:10 describes the Lake of Fire as being in God's presence. The fire and brimstone that burns the damned emanates from God's presence in Isaiah 30:33 and II Thessalonians 1:8-9. God Himself is called a consuming fire in Deuteronomy 4:24 and Hebrews 12:29. And Deuteronomy 32:22 also defined the fire of judgment as coming from God. So it's neither "outer" nor "darkness".
New Jerusalem is defined as where the Light is in Revelation 21:23-25. Then verse 26 contradicts those who insist all the Saved are the Lambs Wife, it says there are Nations of the Saved outside New Jerusalem. The people listed here though still get to come to New Jerusalem to worship it seems.
Revelation 22:5 returns to discussing how New Jerusalem is where the Light is.
People who are Universalists of some kind like to point to Revelation 22:15, where it seems to them like the same people sent into the Lake of Fire earlier are now merely outside The City. And you can't argue the Lake of Fire is outside the City because I already showed it is The Presence of God.
People who teach Salvation can be lost (or the fifth point of Calvinism/false repentance doctrine) love to use 1 Corinthians 6:9-10, Galatians 5:21 and Ephesians 5:5. All these are vice lists warning that those who continue in those sins will not Inherit the Kingdom, and they're clearly warnings to already Saved Believers. But they do not say salvation can be lost, only inheritance. Like the Prodigal Son a Believer can squander his inheritance but he'll never lose his Sonship. They are the believers not allowed to enter New Jerusalem.
The Bema Judgment will not be a Judgment where anyone is really scolded or punished for their Sins. It is a handing out of Rewards only. But one of those Rewards is for keeping your Flesh under control, the Imperishable or Incorruptible Crown.
Luke 8's account of the Parable of the Sower divides people who hear the word into four groups in verses 12-15. Only the first, those who never believed, are described as unsaved. There are people who will believe for a little while and fall way, I discussed Hebrews 6 elsewhere. Also there are those that are believers till the end but are also very worldly. And then those that are fruitful. Only the Fruitful I think will really be New Jerusalem.
Friday, October 24, 2014
Rape in The Bible
Did you know The Bible actually depicts and condemns an example of Female on Male Rape? People miss it because they go into it with their Rape Culture "Men can't be Raped" attitude. But Lot was Raped by his own Daughters. Yet people commonly treat it like it's just about Incest.
Lot did not "Get drunk and impregnate his daughters" as some describe it. His daughters got him drunk and made him impregnate them. And they premeditated doing it. Genesis 19:32 "Come, let us make our father drink wine, and we will lie with him, that we may preserve seed of our father."
You may be assuming his daughters were very young. Their age isn't specified, but there is reason to suspect they were born before Lot ever came to Sodom. Even if they were born soon after, Lot had been in Sodom for probably over 20 years before this happened.
Some people also have it in their head The Bible doesn't condemn anyone's actions in this story just because the narrative voice doesn't stop to say "and what they did was wrong". The Bible often does things that way, especially in Genesis.
The Bible condemns examples of Rape various times. But the part of The Law of Moses that is the civil law code of Israel is like plenty else in The Law imperfect in how issues are addressed. Because while given by God it's still a Law Code for an imperfect fallen world.
Anyone who studies Jewish attitudes to their Law knows the intent of The Law matters. And Besides murder every capital offense in The Torah is only meant to be viewed as a maximum penalty not a minimum one.
Only if a Woman is betrothed or married would her having any sex outside marriage be a capitol offense. And we see with how Joseph handled Mary's situation that the Groom/Husband is fully allowed to simply drop the charges.
Lot did not "Get drunk and impregnate his daughters" as some describe it. His daughters got him drunk and made him impregnate them. And they premeditated doing it. Genesis 19:32 "Come, let us make our father drink wine, and we will lie with him, that we may preserve seed of our father."
You may be assuming his daughters were very young. Their age isn't specified, but there is reason to suspect they were born before Lot ever came to Sodom. Even if they were born soon after, Lot had been in Sodom for probably over 20 years before this happened.
Some people also have it in their head The Bible doesn't condemn anyone's actions in this story just because the narrative voice doesn't stop to say "and what they did was wrong". The Bible often does things that way, especially in Genesis.
The Bible condemns examples of Rape various times. But the part of The Law of Moses that is the civil law code of Israel is like plenty else in The Law imperfect in how issues are addressed. Because while given by God it's still a Law Code for an imperfect fallen world.
Anyone who studies Jewish attitudes to their Law knows the intent of The Law matters. And Besides murder every capital offense in The Torah is only meant to be viewed as a maximum penalty not a minimum one.
Only if a Woman is betrothed or married would her having any sex outside marriage be a capitol offense. And we see with how Joseph handled Mary's situation that the Groom/Husband is fully allowed to simply drop the charges.
Deuteronomy 22:24 is attacked because people read it as "All the Rapist has to do is cover her Mouth and he'd get away with it". That's not the intent, the intent is clear that if It's Rape she shouldn't be executed. And He wouldn't get away with it, he gets killed no matter what.
If I wanted to I could attack Deuteronomy 22:25-27 from the other way. It seems to be an exception to the usual rule of needing two witnesses. A betrothed Damsel could just say some random guy raped her in the field and no proof is needed, he'd just be dead. If we take this law at face value. Today it's politically incorrect to suggest a woman would ever make a false Rape accusation, and the way this law is set up suggests to me the Bible's authors might have agreed with modern SJWs on this. The only false Rape accusation in The Bible is what lands Joseph in prison in Egypt, and that was a woman far more privileged then most. If The Bible mentions something only once, you can't build doctrine on it.
Deuteronomy 22:28-29 is repeatedly refereed to as if it not only explicitly included Rape but was specifically about Rape. (That's partly because it's mistranslated in versions other then the KJV). And that it's saying a unbetrothed woman who's raped is forced to marry her Rapist.
First of all it doesn't in this case even address if it's Rape, and the point is not about the Woman but about the Man's responsibly to a Woman who's virginity he takes. I think most Rabbis would agree that it's implied neither the woman or her father is required to do anything, and that if he refused to accept the Silver no marriage happens.
Deuteronomy means the second giving of the law, almost every law in it is repeated from earlier. This specific situation is a less detailed repeat of Exodus 22:16-17.
Both these passages are clearly different wording expressing the same thing. And it's purely the modern world's fixation on attacking the Bible that has made Deuteronomy's version more famous. This part of Exodus is where any good study of The Law should begin. It's repeated at all only to ensure it's importance is understood.
The word translated entice in the KJV is sometimes translated "seduce". Many ancient languages used the same words for seduction and rape. Both this Hebrew word and the one rendered "lay hold" in Deuteronomy includes according to Strongs an implication of deception in their meaning.
Deuteronomy means the second giving of the law, almost every law in it is repeated from earlier. This specific situation is a less detailed repeat of Exodus 22:16-17.
And if a man entice a maid that is not betrothed, and lie with her, he shall surely endow her to be his wife. If her father utterly refuse to give her unto him, he shall pay money according to the dowry of virgins.When it's acknowledged at all, an annoying perception exists on one site that Deuteronomy is specifically about rape and Exodus is specifically about if it's consensual. But use common sense, even the law codes that are the worst on Rape have never made a Rape victim more guilty then a woman who has sex consensually. The problems come from people refusing to acknowledge rape.
Both these passages are clearly different wording expressing the same thing. And it's purely the modern world's fixation on attacking the Bible that has made Deuteronomy's version more famous. This part of Exodus is where any good study of The Law should begin. It's repeated at all only to ensure it's importance is understood.
The word translated entice in the KJV is sometimes translated "seduce". Many ancient languages used the same words for seduction and rape. Both this Hebrew word and the one rendered "lay hold" in Deuteronomy includes according to Strongs an implication of deception in their meaning.
In the case of Amnon's rape of Tamar however she does reference back to this Law and condemn him for not obeying it. Modern women I know can't possibly relate to the idea that a woman would want to marry the man that raped her. But women 3000 years ago were in a very different situation. They mostly needed to be married to even survive. That's why Jesus said that a man forces his Wife to commit Adultery by remarriage if he divorces her.
Thursday, October 23, 2014
Appealing to the Early Church Fathers
In the letters to the Seven Churches there is only one Doctrine Jesus said he hates. The Doctrine of the Nicolatians. Which means "conquerors of the lay people".
Appealing to Church Authority or Tradition, no matter how old, is this Doctrine. Yet even people who are correct in identifying what that doctrine is fall into the trap of doing just that.
People want to cite various passages from The Epistles foretelling the arising of False Doctrines as relevant to their objections to what are viewed as inherently modern heresies. But Paul said ravenous wolves would arise teaching these doctrines as soon as he departed (Acts 20:29). And he dealt with people teaching wrong things during his life also, as did John.
There is a tendency to view Catholicism as beginning with Constantine, but that's not true. Pergamos had all the basic qualities of Catholicism when Revelation was written. All the people we call Early Church Fathers were trying to reconcile Christianity with Rome. The book called 1 Clement teaches Apostolic succession and the supremacy of the Roman Bishop is heavily implied.
Critics of Eternal Security love to insist no one taught it before Calvin, and the non Calivnist form (what I believe) emerged in America in the 1800s.
Clement of Rome is the only of the "Apostalic fathers" who's words we have directly that we have Scriptural verification did in fact know the Apostles. Ignatias and Polycorp we think knew them based on their own word or their followers words. Only First Clement is legit, the other works attributed to him are forgeries.
But even in First Clement he's teaching Apostolic Succession, that's the point of the letter actually. And implying the supremacy of Rome since he thinks it's his business to tell the Corinthians what to do. And he believed the pagan myth of the Phoenix to be true, he cited it as a fact and tried using it prove a point.
Still, Clement did teach by Faith Alone how Protestants and Evangelicals define it in chapters 32-33. And the things quoted from him used against Eternal Security do not really say that, he encourages us to do good works, but says nothing to imply he thinks it's possible for a person to be Saved yet later wind him in Hell.
As I said in an earlier post the epistle of Barnabas was not written by Barnabas. That epistle fails to even properly teach Salvation by Faith alone.
Maybe it is true all the Church Fathers seem to have been unanimous against Eternal Security. But to say the doctrine didn't exist is wrong. Origen clearly refers to it being taught by "Heretics".
History is written by the winners. The Nag Hamadi collection seems to have shown Irenaeus to have been basically accurate in how he represented the Gnostics (his critics nitpick some things he said of course). The problem is there is a tendency to confuse the Gnostics with other groups. And that may have existed among some of their contemporary critics as well.
My point is, we should maybe consider that some groups like the Montanists were completely misrepresented. And perhaps were really hated mainly for believing in Eternal Security, and/or that the Covenant with Israel as a nation still stood. Or simply in some way threatening the church hierarchy.
If you're against Replacement Theology and appeal to the Church Fathers in opposition to Eternal Security, you're a hypocrite. They were equally unanimous on that. Likewise if you believe in Eternal Security and appeal to the Church Fathers to back up your support of Replacement theology.
And if you disagree with them on either of those positions, but especially both, and then appeal to the Church Fathers to express your disagreement with my views on Sexual Morality, especially Homosexuality. You're very hypocritical. Because there is far less they said on Homosexuality then on those issues. See the Post I already linked back to.
Also if KJV only you shouldn't like the Church Fathers on the Old Testament, they favored the Septuagint over the Masoretic text. until Jerome at least.
I don't question any of their salvation, many were Martyred for the Faith and I don't consider it possible for a fake believer to become a Martyr. But they were not Biblically sound.
Eternal Security is perhaps a more valid issue to consider them relevant. Since those who hold it see it as foundational to the Gospel itself. But to me the evidence it existed is sufficient.
At least one Early Church Father's main quote on saying Salvation can be lost is one that most honest opponents to Eternal Security must agree is the weakest of all verses they use. The phrase "He that Endureth to the End shall be Saved" from Matthew 10 and 24, which are Eschatological and about surviving Persecution to be Saved by Christ's return, NOT Eternal Salvation. And even then the verses don't say who doesn't wont be saved, that's just something read into it. The point is that failing to endure isn't Sin in those verses but dying.
The point is, no matter how unanimous Church Opinions may have seemed. Scripture alone is the Inspired Infallible Word of God.
I don't know whether or not John Chrysostom believed in Eternal Security. But he does have a quote that speaks to how I'd respond to those who view Calvinism and Eternal Security inseparable. Who assert that you can't believe we're Saved by our Free Will if we can't also lose it.
My annoyance on the Eternal Security issue is how the mere fact that the Church Fathers themselves didn't teach it is considered proof that it didn't exist, and yet I have found examples of those same Church Father teaching against it.
Augustine of Hippo in City of God, 21:17-27 addresses many varied views of Salvation that existed at this time. In 26 he says.
After Augustine's day, Bede writes against those who believe "that it does not matter whether they live evil lives or do wicked and terrible things, as long as they believe in Christ, because salvation is through faith" (JPJ, 31).
Jerome's writings seem to have contradictions. Sounding sometimes like a Universalist and sometimes like he believes in a very Non-Calvinist Eternal Security.
It seems Hilary, Jerome, Abmrose and Abmrosiaster taught an early form of Purgutory. Dividing people's fate at the Judgment into 3 Camps. The Ungodly who with he Devil will burn forever. The Sanctified who go directly to Heaven. And the average Christians who need to be "Purged by fire". They probably got this "purged by fire" notion from a misunderstanding of what Paul said in 1 Corinthians 3:15 about the Bema Judgment. That there will be believers who get no rewards because their good deeds were all burned up, but they are still saved.
Tertullian truly proves problematic in Against Marcion, where he goes overboard in opposing Marcion's use of Paul to assert Paul is not a valid Apostle at all, and in that work he seems to oppose even By Faith Alone. He also does not even consider the Four Gospels equal.
Also a number of these early fathers cited for their opposition to Eternal Security were Universalists.
Appealing to Church Authority or Tradition, no matter how old, is this Doctrine. Yet even people who are correct in identifying what that doctrine is fall into the trap of doing just that.
People want to cite various passages from The Epistles foretelling the arising of False Doctrines as relevant to their objections to what are viewed as inherently modern heresies. But Paul said ravenous wolves would arise teaching these doctrines as soon as he departed (Acts 20:29). And he dealt with people teaching wrong things during his life also, as did John.
There is a tendency to view Catholicism as beginning with Constantine, but that's not true. Pergamos had all the basic qualities of Catholicism when Revelation was written. All the people we call Early Church Fathers were trying to reconcile Christianity with Rome. The book called 1 Clement teaches Apostolic succession and the supremacy of the Roman Bishop is heavily implied.
Critics of Eternal Security love to insist no one taught it before Calvin, and the non Calivnist form (what I believe) emerged in America in the 1800s.
Clement of Rome is the only of the "Apostalic fathers" who's words we have directly that we have Scriptural verification did in fact know the Apostles. Ignatias and Polycorp we think knew them based on their own word or their followers words. Only First Clement is legit, the other works attributed to him are forgeries.
But even in First Clement he's teaching Apostolic Succession, that's the point of the letter actually. And implying the supremacy of Rome since he thinks it's his business to tell the Corinthians what to do. And he believed the pagan myth of the Phoenix to be true, he cited it as a fact and tried using it prove a point.
Still, Clement did teach by Faith Alone how Protestants and Evangelicals define it in chapters 32-33. And the things quoted from him used against Eternal Security do not really say that, he encourages us to do good works, but says nothing to imply he thinks it's possible for a person to be Saved yet later wind him in Hell.
As I said in an earlier post the epistle of Barnabas was not written by Barnabas. That epistle fails to even properly teach Salvation by Faith alone.
Maybe it is true all the Church Fathers seem to have been unanimous against Eternal Security. But to say the doctrine didn't exist is wrong. Origen clearly refers to it being taught by "Heretics".
“Certain ones of those [heretics] who hold different opinions misuse these passages. They essentially destroy free will be introducing ruined natures incapable of salvation and by introducing others as being saved in such a way that they cannot be lost.” ~ Origen (c. 225)At first glance this might sound like the Claivnist form. But he may have been misrepresenting what they taught. And on the incapable of Salvation part he perhaps only meant what many non Calvinists theorize about the Unpardonable Sin (that a person can become "Reprobate" and unsaveble). Or it could be these were two beliefs Origen considered wrong "Belief in Salvation that can't be lost, and belief in people who can't be saved", that he affiliates with each other here, but weren't necessarily believed by the same people, or at least not always.
History is written by the winners. The Nag Hamadi collection seems to have shown Irenaeus to have been basically accurate in how he represented the Gnostics (his critics nitpick some things he said of course). The problem is there is a tendency to confuse the Gnostics with other groups. And that may have existed among some of their contemporary critics as well.
My point is, we should maybe consider that some groups like the Montanists were completely misrepresented. And perhaps were really hated mainly for believing in Eternal Security, and/or that the Covenant with Israel as a nation still stood. Or simply in some way threatening the church hierarchy.
If you're against Replacement Theology and appeal to the Church Fathers in opposition to Eternal Security, you're a hypocrite. They were equally unanimous on that. Likewise if you believe in Eternal Security and appeal to the Church Fathers to back up your support of Replacement theology.
And if you disagree with them on either of those positions, but especially both, and then appeal to the Church Fathers to express your disagreement with my views on Sexual Morality, especially Homosexuality. You're very hypocritical. Because there is far less they said on Homosexuality then on those issues. See the Post I already linked back to.
Also if KJV only you shouldn't like the Church Fathers on the Old Testament, they favored the Septuagint over the Masoretic text. until Jerome at least.
I don't question any of their salvation, many were Martyred for the Faith and I don't consider it possible for a fake believer to become a Martyr. But they were not Biblically sound.
Eternal Security is perhaps a more valid issue to consider them relevant. Since those who hold it see it as foundational to the Gospel itself. But to me the evidence it existed is sufficient.
At least one Early Church Father's main quote on saying Salvation can be lost is one that most honest opponents to Eternal Security must agree is the weakest of all verses they use. The phrase "He that Endureth to the End shall be Saved" from Matthew 10 and 24, which are Eschatological and about surviving Persecution to be Saved by Christ's return, NOT Eternal Salvation. And even then the verses don't say who doesn't wont be saved, that's just something read into it. The point is that failing to endure isn't Sin in those verses but dying.
The point is, no matter how unanimous Church Opinions may have seemed. Scripture alone is the Inspired Infallible Word of God.
I don't know whether or not John Chrysostom believed in Eternal Security. But he does have a quote that speaks to how I'd respond to those who view Calvinism and Eternal Security inseparable. Who assert that you can't believe we're Saved by our Free Will if we can't also lose it.
“All is in God’s power, but so that our free-will is not lost...it depends therefore on us and on Him. We must first choose the good, and then He adds what belongs to Him. He does not precede our willing, that our free-will may not suffer. But when we have chosen, then He affords us much help...It is ours to choose beforehand and to will, but God’s to perfect and bring to the end.” (On Hebrews, Homily 12)Here is another blogger on this subject. But I do not agree with everything he says. Here is one on what I must qualify is a Calvinist blog. It's about Justification by Faith alone not specifically Eternal Security. But some quotes alluding to it's existence are there. Contrary to Catholic and Orthodox critics the Early Church absolutely DID teach Justification by Faith Alone, as we Evangelicals define it. Here the same Calvinist blog deals with Eternal Security.
My annoyance on the Eternal Security issue is how the mere fact that the Church Fathers themselves didn't teach it is considered proof that it didn't exist, and yet I have found examples of those same Church Father teaching against it.
Augustine of Hippo in City of God, 21:17-27 addresses many varied views of Salvation that existed at this time. In 26 he says.
"But, say they, the catholic Christians have Christ for a foundation, and they have not fallen away from union with Him, no matter how depraved a life they have built on this foundation, as wood, hay, stubble; and accordingly the well-directed faith by which Christ is their foundation will suffice to deliver them some time from the continuance of that fire, though it be with loss, since those things they have built on it shall be burned. Let the Apostle James summarily reply to them: ‘If any man say he has faith, and have not works, can faith save him?’”His misuse of James here is common in modern attacks on Eternal Security and Salvation by Faith alone. He is quoting a question not an answer.
After Augustine's day, Bede writes against those who believe "that it does not matter whether they live evil lives or do wicked and terrible things, as long as they believe in Christ, because salvation is through faith" (JPJ, 31).
Jerome's writings seem to have contradictions. Sounding sometimes like a Universalist and sometimes like he believes in a very Non-Calvinist Eternal Security.
"Just as we believe that the torments of the Devil, of all the deniers of God, of the ungodly who have said in their hearts, 'there is no God,' will be eternal, so too do we believe that the judgment of Christian sinners, whose works will be tried and purged in fire will be moderate and mixed with clemency.' Furthermore, 'He who with all his spirit has placed his faith in Christ, even if he die in sin, shall by his faith live forever."But he also said things contradicting that elsewhere.
It seems Hilary, Jerome, Abmrose and Abmrosiaster taught an early form of Purgutory. Dividing people's fate at the Judgment into 3 Camps. The Ungodly who with he Devil will burn forever. The Sanctified who go directly to Heaven. And the average Christians who need to be "Purged by fire". They probably got this "purged by fire" notion from a misunderstanding of what Paul said in 1 Corinthians 3:15 about the Bema Judgment. That there will be believers who get no rewards because their good deeds were all burned up, but they are still saved.
Tertullian truly proves problematic in Against Marcion, where he goes overboard in opposing Marcion's use of Paul to assert Paul is not a valid Apostle at all, and in that work he seems to oppose even By Faith Alone. He also does not even consider the Four Gospels equal.
Also a number of these early fathers cited for their opposition to Eternal Security were Universalists.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)