Monday, January 6, 2025

Census Before Cyrenius was Governor

So I have become aware of another solution to the Luke 2 Census issue thanks to this PDF.

THE CENSUS AND QUIRINIUS: LUKE 2:2 by Wayne Brinale

This answer is on Page 7 of the PDF saying page 48 at the top. 

I shall now Copy/Paste some form it.
Feldman, in his edition of Josephus, states that "Luke 2:2 can be vindicated only if we translate ... , This census was the first before that under the prefectureship of Quirinius in Syria.'  The adjective prötos may mean "first" or "earlier," "former,".

"First census" must be taken in its Hellenistic connotation as the first of two, and then we must expand the clause a little. "This census was before the census which Quirinius, governor of Syria, made."
I am personally annoyed on why so many think the well known Census of the Empire taken in 8 BC can't fit this even when they are not identifying it with AD 6. Is it just lack of a formal "Decree"?

Again Tertulian says Saturninus was Governor of Syria when Jesus was born without any acknowledgment of how Luke seemingly says someone else was Governor.

And a 8 BC Nativity could have the Passover when Jesus was 12 be the first one after Archelaus died. 

Some people have in their heads that the Nativity wasn't just before Herod died but son before, but I don't know where that comes from.  

In Matthew 2 there is all kinds of ambiguity about how much time separates the Birth of Jesus from the visit of the Magi or the Visit of the magi form when Herod decided to slaughter the innocents.  But more importantly then those gaps we have no idea how long they were in Egypt, it could have been years. 

No comments:

Post a Comment